Sylvia's Lovers, set towards the end of the eighteenth century in the town of Monkshaven (a thinly veiled and beautifully described Whitby) tells the tale of the local beauty, Sylvia, and the two men who vie for her affections: quiet, thoughtful Philip Hepburn and charismatic, serial heart-breaker Charley Kinraid. Against this drama of local passions a larger story plays itself out as the inhabitants of the town find themselves at the mercy of press-gangs, keen to snatch sailors from the whaling ships and force them into service against the French. The two suitors spa with each other as the town finds itself more at odds with the English navy than with the supposedly hostile but never seen raiders from France.
What makes the novel so striking is the quality of Gaskell's writing. Towards the beginning of the book a local lad dies during a skirmish with the press-gang and the description of his burial, with virtually the whole town in attendance at the windswept church, and with the relatives sobbing beneath a slate-grey sky as the bells toll and the waves crash against the shore far below is so exquisitely depicted as to be genuinely moving. Gaskell was also good at analysing what makes people tick - her descriptions of the local shop girl Hester Rose, quietly besotted with Philip who, in turn, is barely even aware that she exists, tell you all you could ever wish to know about the wretched misery of unrequited love.
Gaskell described Sylvia's Lovers as the saddest story she ever wrote but while it does contain episodes that even Thomas Hardy might have regarded as unduly pessimistic (well, almost....) there are occasions during the later half of the novel when the story veers away from tragedy and stumbles dangerously close to melodrama. The book has a slightly uneven feel, with the first half reading like Middlemarch (a beautiful evocation of town life and the passions of the inhabitants) while the latter occasionally reads like East Lynne (general all-round hysteria) but in a sense by making the first part of her book so elegant Gaskell was able to show how quickly and spectacularly things can fall apart when tragedy strikes. The book may be uneven but then, on many occasions, so is life. After all the grandest of passions and the greatest of tragedies can play themselves out in the most unexpected of places and the most seemingly quiet of lives. Highly recommended, if you fancy a little drama in your reading life.