I first read this book, at my friend's insistence, in 1995 while away on a vacation weekend. For the whole weekend I walked around with it under my nose- simply unwilling to put it down. It was the first paperback romance that I had read and I was, quite frankly, not expecting to find any substance to it - feeling superior as I did, to the kinds of people, who I imagined must read this frothy frivolous type of "literature".( I'm sure other romance readers are familiar with this condescension from those who would never be caught reading a book of this genre.) To my chagrin, I found the book completely fascinating, and for quite some time afterwards, my thoughts returned to the lead characters, and to the images formed from the many intricately detailed descriptions depicting that terrible time in European history. And so, five years later, on the reissue of Surrender to A Strange, I find myself highly recommending this book. In fact, I give it the highest recommendation. This recommendation does not, however, come without warnings:
First of all, be prepared to be disturbed. The macabre evil images of shocking cruelty; of horrific degradation suffered by so many, at the hands of the confused masses gone mad - these images of the most base despicable actions of mankind .may not put you in a light-hearted mood. Are you ready for this darkness?
Secondly, be prepared to not immediately like the young heroine. While she, Jacqueline, is admirably strong-willed, brave and dignified from page 1, she is also unattractively haughty and her self-assured belief that she is a superior creature endowed with noble virtues because of her aristocratic birth and upbringing is sure to irritate many readers. But for me, this allowed a most interesting development of character to take place and so added further richness to this moving story. By the latter half of the story, we find the heroine's thinking about "the filthy common peasant" and the vulgar profit-driven bourgeoisie profoundly altered. Jacqueline's testy and passionate relationship with the magnificent wiser and older hero, plus her encounters with a common street urchin bring her a new understanding of what makes people decent, worthy and honorable. And in learning this lesson Jacqueline's true and glorious colours are ultimately revealed. Brilliantly done.
It is also possible, that some readers will not approve of Jacqueline's desperate need to avenge the wrongful deaths of her father and brother - because it means abandoning perhaps forever, her two young sisters. This obsessive need for revenge seems unconscionable to us, as most of us have not been raised to believe, as the noble classes of that time were, that vengeance and honor -killings were obligatory actions, duties of the highest order to family, country and king. These days most of us admire those who are strong and compassionate enough to "love thy enemy", and who fight for causes, not with bloodshed, but perhaps using the passive-resistance style of say, Mahatma Gandhi. Not so then. In my opinion, a good part of what makes this story so worthwhile is Karyn Monk's understanding and portrayal of the very different views of honorable behavior that existed in society at the close of feudalism in Europe.
A final warning to the reader who may take this book to a public place to read, - beware the first love scene! Here are images so tantalizingly exquisitely erotic, that you would be well advised to read them in a setting where any sighs or heightened color in your cheeks are not noticed by passers-by! It is testimony to Karyn Monk's superb finesse as a descriptive writer that she can create such a moving vicarious experience for her readers' pleasure. I imagine that the obligatory love scenes required by this genre of story, could be easily turned farcical by the wrong choice of words (think of the stereotype of the sex scenes in such books- all heaving bosom and rising manhood - often ridiculous). Ms. Monk's portrayal, on the other hand, is pure poetry. Enough said, I recommend this book to anyone who wants a challenging worthwhile story to read. See for yourself. I predict it will leave a lasting impression.