When I first heard about the Edsel Suede reissues, the thing I was sold on the the inclusion of "Love & Poison" on the DVD. Then I saw the packaging and thought "Nice!"... OK, I've got "Sci-Fi Lullabies", I don't need the b-sides and the thing is, anyone interested enough to buy these re-issues has probably already got that wonderful b-sides compilation album (and if they haven't, they can get it cheaply on eBay, like I did.)
Nevertheless, ordered the debut and "Dog Man Star" straight away.
I ignored the CDs first off and went straight to the DVD for the debut. Another camcorder show just like the one that disappointed me on the "Dog Man Star" reissue which arrived first. Except this one has quite good sound and is generally quite a good show, exciting and makes you wish you'd been old enough to see Suede in 1993.
The promos videos were all good but I already have the "Lost In TV" DVD.
Then "Love & Poison". Seems to have come from a VHS, just like my own copy I own! Hmm, isn't there a master out there for this?! Anyway, good show, good sound, as good as we'll get for now... EXCEPT there's a problem. Watching "Love & Poison", halfway through I realised the audio and video were drifting VERY out of sync with each other. Many others on forums have noticed this and the blame seems to lie with the fact that all this video was recorded on PAL and Edsel, trying to capture as much of a market as possible converted the whole lot to NTSC... and whichever methods they used to do this resulted in this huge flaw. I can't even watch it the sync is so far out. Thanks Edsel for screwing over both your markets by
On a positive note the albums sounds nice remastered. It's louder anyway. The interesting Island and Rocking Horse demos are mostly from cassette copies by the sound (tape wobble, dropouts and all) of it and not master tapes. Do the master tapes exist? I don't know.
Then, like a previous reviewer, why didn't they mop up those really early unreleased tracks such as "Be My God", "Art" and the early demos? Well, Suede had nearly all 500 copies of the "Be My God/Art" single destroyed at the time because they weren't happy. I don't think they would've liked their inclusion on this reissue. Personally, that approach just makes you feel like the reissues are halfway done.
So, I'm off to contact Edsel/Demon about the audio sync issue on the DVD. I suggest anyone else that cares enough does the same until they are forced to correct this, free of charge. Such a missed opportunity for such a brilliant debut album.