This book was incredibly difficult to put down. I knew it was a work of fiction, but the fact that it was based on real events made it all seem more real to me and even though I wanted all the children to survive, I knew that they wouldn't.
The story is fast paced and Lorenzo Carcaterra's language makes the war torn city of Naples come alive inside the reader's mind. Most characters in the book seem very real. They all have their faults and fears, but still manage a heroic feat.
The reason I'm giving it 4 stars rather than 5 is the language issue. In Mr Carcaterra's world all these young street kids in 1940's Naples all of a sudden speak fluent English and are also able to understand what German soldiers are saying to each other. The German soldiers speak broken Italian, but all seem to speak English. This is just taking fiction a bit too far. It wouldn't have done the story any harm to have the characters of various nationalities have problems understanding each other.
Finally, if you have any knowledge of Italian you need to temporarily forget it when you read this book. I wish the editors had taken time to have the Italian language bits (a few sentences here and there) corrected. Even allowing for the Neapolitan dialect being different from Italian, it's painful to read if you speak Italian and it wouldn't have taken long to have it corrected. It almost made me rate the book as a 3, but then I realised that most people who read it won't notice the difference.