This compilation hardly does justice to the wealth of music Carter have produced, but nevertheless provides a good summary for those not familiar with the band. The social commentry that runs throughout Carter's music is everpresent in Straw Donkey, from their humble beginnings with tracks like 'Sheltered Life', through to their lastest efforts with the "Young Offender's Mum" and "Born on the 5th of November". It would be nice to have heard some more material from "30 Something", but then, Straw Donkey wasn't compiled for me! If you like Carter, buy Straw Donkey; if you love Carter, buy the albums first, then buy Straw Donkey.