It's been a while since a notable soprano made a recording of Strauss's orchestral songs. The composer had a light, silvery lyric voice in mind when he composed many of these (his wife Pauline possessed such a voice, along with a notoriously shrewish temper), and she must have been quite accomplished, given the coloratura demands of, for example, "Ich wollt ein Struasslein binden," the first item on the program. Diana Damrau handles it beautifully, moving through the tricky melisma with a steady, beautiful tone and winning manner. I haven't heard her in person, but if the microphones place her front and center, there's no issue of such a light soprano having to ride over Strauss's lush orchestral writing. She makes a good deal out of the poetry, too, which is welcome; I think this is the most expressive singing, so far as language goes, since Schwarzkopf's famous Strauss collection under Szell four decades ago.
Damrau has emerged as a star, particularly on stage, where she is said to be a compelling actress; on disc, however, I've tended to find her coy and mannered, expending too much effort on histrionics. That isn't so here. Under the expert guidance of Christian Thielemann, who has made a name for himself conducting Strauss operas around the world, the singer is bright and forward but respectful of limits. It's hard for a coloratura soprano to sound as serious as a richer voice would, but she overcomes this innate difficulty well. I wasn't as emotionally involved as with notable Straussians form the past like Schwarzkopf, Gueden, and Della Casa, yet in her lighter way Damrau is quite successful, particularly if you are listening for ravishing sound from voice and orchestra, which has certainly been supplied by EMI's excellent engineering.
Twenty-two songs is a generous number -- too generous, perhaps, since a long stretch of Strauss's luscious melodies turns into musical marzipan after a wile. But taken eight or nine at a time, they are delightful, and all the chestnuts are here. Damrau joins Felicity Lott and Renee Fleming as a leading exponent of this repertoire among recent singers. Among the men, I'd plump for Steve Davislim, although the great Fritz Wunderlich also recorded a handful, taken from radio broadcasts as I recall, not studio sessions.