Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Informative, comprehensive but not _quite_ full marks, 19 Feb 2002
This review is from: Storming Eagles: German Paratroopers in World War Two (Cassell Military Paperbacks) (Paperback)
The overall impression I got from reading Storming Eagles was that it was informative, readable but slightly dry. The subtitle, "German Airborne Forces in WWII', gives the scope of the book - being a history of the Fallschirmjaeger from its early pre-war days as a parachute police force, to the dilution of its roll from the small-scale, parachute delivered surprise commando force (envisaged by the Luftwaffe) to the large scale, aeroplane delivered conventional (albeit elite) infantry which it later became (as perceived by the army) in order to merely plug gaps in the failing German lines. The strengths of the book are its comprehensive family tree of structural development and its timeline of operations. If you want to know how a certain Jaeger Regiment metamorphosed from a Flieger Corps, and in what year, then this is the book for you. If you want a potted history of every conflict in which the Green Devils were thrust then you'll find this book valuable. Its weaknesses were that - though I raced through the book, which suggests it can't have been _that_ dry, it didn't quite engage me. I think it lacked a human dimension in some way. I can't really put my finger on why I feel like this because the explanations of the prelude and the importance of each major operation are clear and well illustrated with maps; also, there are first-person accounts of some experiences in particular operations: the usual stories of courage and hardship. I just don't think there were enough of these - not in the same way, for example, that Cornelius Ryan blends the strategic overview with the detail of personal struggles at the front line in his superb 'A Bridge Too Far'. This may be because Ryan focused on one operation whereas Lucas throws his net wider. I suspect what I'm getting around to is that the book was too short to truly satisfy - all the important information was there, but the potted history needed rounding off with more personal accounts, more background on the development of parachuting and the role of parachutists and more illustrations and detail on the weapons and equipment of the Fallschirmjaeger - most or all of this IS covered in the book, some in the dedicated appendices - but just tantalizingly not quite enough.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful narrative by a Fallschirmjäger aficionado, 23 May 2008
By Bjorn Hansson - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Storming Eagles: German Airborne Forces in World War II (Hardcover)
Highly recommended for anyone interested in German paratroopers or special forces in general. Great narrative, very easy to read. Every battle is viewed through the eyes of the German paratroopers. Thus the usual monster battles, Stalingrad etc. gets very little focus or are hardly even mentioned. Whereas entire chapters are devoted to the operations in Benelux and Tunisia. This doesn't feel odd at all, but actually very refreshing since you are reading THEIR, sometimes untold, story.
The book is written in a style that blends detailed eye-witness accounts with broader strokes of operational history. This is of course the most common way to write military history books, but James Lucas does so better than most authors. He does not bog down in unnecessary details, yet manages to keep the reader aware of which unit was where and why.
Mr. Lucas holds the German paratroppers very dear, yet he comes of as well balanced and unbiased is his interpretation of the events.
The one negative thing I have to say about the book is the lack of maps (an all to common problem in this genre). To fully enjoy it you need to have a healthy dose of WW2 geography in your backpack. Still it doesn't cause enough fuss to give the book anything other than the highest grade.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
German Paratroops--Fallshirmjager Units, 29 Jun 2005
By Kay's Husband - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Storming Eagles: German Paratroopers in World War Two (Cassell Military Paperbacks) (Paperback)
Having a dozen & more WWII books on the shelf by James Lucas, you could say that I do enjoy his books. I trust his research and scholarship whenever he writes about the WWII era.
This present volume, originally published in 1988 by Arms and Armour Press, is now available in a lower priced Cassell paperback war classic.
These tough, well trained men who wore the Parachutist's jump badge of the silver wreath with the golden eagle descending, were some of Germany's finest special forces groups. From 1935 through 1945, these men were generally in the thick of combat wherever the Reich needed them most. And from the 1940 assault on Eben Emael and the invasion of Crete in 1941 onward they took on the patina and glimmer of a hard, tough fighting group. In the final days of 1945 when the British were assaulting the Westwall and Reichswald, the "bloody para boys" were the ones they least wanted to face. These hardened troops also saw action in the key theatres of North West Europe, North Africa, and on the Eastern Front.
James Lucas covers all aspects of this specialized group of men from 1940 through 1945, and does it pretty much in historical order. Hardly a page in this book exists without photographs (hardcover edition) and the maps are excellent, too.
Should you have interest in any of the special forces of the Reich, especially these fallshirmjagers, then this book is one you must see.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Eagles or Green Devils, Warriors All, 7 April 2007
By Mannie Liscum - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Storming Eagles: German Airborne Forces in World War II (Hardcover)
Storming Eagles: German Airborne Forces in World War II by James Lucas is a fascinating book, written not as a piece of Fallschirmjaeger ideology, nor as pointed anti-German prose from a former British soldier who faced these warriors (as Lucas was), but rather as a clear-headed and balanced account of the actions of these German troops throughout the Second World War. Lucas has crafted his prose in such a way that readers from an Allied lineage will away not feeling as though they have been reading about the 'enemy' as much as having read about groups of elite well-trained, valorous and tenacious soldiers who fought bravely for their country in the great conflict that was WWII. This is not an easy task for an author as so much emotion is still (60 odd year out) connected with this conflict and nationalism of readers is not absent. Yet, on reading Lucas' book this reviewer often felt he was reading not about German paratroopers but units from the 101st or 82nd US Airborne, or British 1st Airborne - one need only substitute names and direction of solider views to accomplish this in a general sense. Lucas achieves this feat by telling personal tales, or at least focusing attention on small units within the larger unit and theatre contexts.
Storming Eagles contains lucid descriptions of the Fallschirmjaeger actions that most will be familiar with (e.g., the drop on Crete in '41), as well as lesser know para-ops (e.g., ****). Yet, the largest portion of the book is devoted to ground actions (no drop or glider troop delivery) of the Jaeger forces, since Hitler concluded early in the War that airborne ops was not efficient use of manpower (much like much of the Allied high command throughout the war) and thus used his elite troops as 'fire-brigades' wherever needed to plug holes or stem Allied pushes. Again it is not hard when reading such accounts to imagine one is reading about Allied airborne forces as those forces were also used as 'fire-brigades' (re: Bastogne during the Ardennes counteroffensive), although certainly not as frequently. As the War proceeded more and more infantry were needed as replacements for dwindling manpower in both Allied and Axis camps, so it should not be that surprising that both commands looked to there elite paratroopers as a source of battle-worthy infantry grunts; better trooper were fighting in ground actions then sitting idle in embarkation camps awaiting airborne ops that never materialized. Lucas gives a good accounting of Jaeger actions throughout the war, a task not made easy by the fact that Hitler chose to utilize these troops piecemeal rather than as whole Divisional units. Hence, the story Lucas presents is one that required rather painstaking research to track down para groups when they were integrated into a variety of Wehrmacht and SS formations scattered in operations from the Middle East, to the Western and Eastern fronts, and actions near the Artic Circle. Lucas' efforts should be lauded, certainly the reader gains from his hard work!
In the end, Storming Eagles is a very solid read worthy of picking up even if one is not especially interested in German paratroops during WWII. This book is valuable for a multitude of reasons and is pure military history fun. 4.5 stars.
|
|
|