Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop All Amazon Fashion Summer Savings Up to 25% Off Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Oasis Listen in Prime Shop now Learn more

Customer Reviews

4.0 out of 5 stars2
4.0 out of 5 stars
5 star
0
4 star
2
3 star
0
2 star
0
1 star
0

Your rating(Clear)Rate this item
Share your thoughts with other customers

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 27 November 2000
If you think tackling the subject of prehistoric ritual sites that you can see (ie. stone circles) is a hard and thankless task often shunned by mainstream archaeology, imagine a book about timber (or pit) circles. Most of these are only seen in aerial photographs, and these require excavation to tell if the pits ever had any posts in them! The book covers the context, dating, possible functions and reconstructions of timber circles. I feel it is a little conservative, more imaginitive speculation (clearly labelled as such) is a feature of Aubrey Burl's books, and is instrumental in making an them interesting to a more casual reader.
Dr Gibson suffered from rather unfortunate timing in the release of this book. Many of the topics are of great interest to those of us who've been following the saga at 'Seahenge', which has thrust the subject of timber circles into the limelight. This book fills in the background lacking in the TV programmes and web sites. In an interesting section on circles in Europe, he refers to a site in Terriers, France that strikes me as quite similar, and of the same data, as Seahenge - two menhirs surrounded by a 12.5m trench containing contiguous timbers, with a radiocarbon date of c.2100 BCE. Gibson describes this site as unique in Europe. It's a great pity this book predates the discovery of Seahenge - indeed a title of Seahenge and Timber Circles might well have shifted some more copies!
Dr Gibson is a prehistorian with English Heritage, indeed he had a fleeting contribution to the Time Team Seahenge special shown in the Winter of 1999. At least one of his prayers has been answered. He writes: "Perhaps the argument is unanswerable, at least until a perfectly preserved, for example waterlogged, site is found... This may be a fanciful dream..."
I don't feel this book has had the recognition it deserves. It's a brave attempt to explain this often overlooked area of archaeology, a difficult subject to bring to life, and this he does well.. If you want to learn more about sites like Seahenge, look no further than this excellent book.
Review by Andy Burnham
0Comment|4 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 18 September 2000
If you think tackling the subject of prehistoric ritual sites that you can see (ie. stone circles) is a hard and thankless task often shunned by mainstream archaeology, imagine a book about timber (or pit) circles. Most of these are only seen in aerial photographs, and these require excavation to tell if the pits ever had any posts in them! The book covers the context, dating, possible functions and reconstructions of timber circles. I feel it is a little conservative, more imaginitive speculation (clearly labelled as such) is a feature of Aubrey Burl's books, and is instrumental in making an them interesting to a more casual reader.
Dr Gibson suffered from rather unfortunate timing in the release of this book. Many of the topics are of great interest to those of us who've been following the saga at 'Seahenge', which has thrust the subject of timber circles into the limelight. This book fills in the background lacking in the TV programmes and web sites. In an interesting section on circles in Europe, he refers to a site in Terriers, France that strikes me as quite similar, and of the same data, as Seahenge - two menhirs surrounded by a 12.5m trench containing contiguous timbers, with a radiocarbon date of c.2100 BCE. Gibson describes this site as unique in Europe. It's a great pity this book predates the discovery of Seahenge - indeed a title of Seahenge and Timber Circles might well have shifted some more copies!
Dr Gibson is a prehistorian with English Heritage, indeed he had a fleeting contribution to the Time Team Seahenge special shown in the Winter of 1999. At least one of his prayers has been answered. He writes: "Perhaps the argument is unanswerable, at least until a perfectly preserved, for example waterlogged, site is found... This may be a fanciful dream..."
I don't feel this book has had the recognition it deserves. It's a brave attempt to explain this often overlooked area of archaeology, a difficult subject to bring to life, and this he does well.. If you want to learn more about sites like Seahenge, look no further than this excellent book.
Review by Andy Burnham
0Comment|One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)