Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
If you read just one book in your life make it this one, 22 Sep 2004
I'm sure any review will not do this book justice. Should have been a bestseller on its release, but I believe it will still get there by word of mouth. This book is captivating and really tugged at my heart strings, the saddest book I have read. The main character creates maps and her enthusiasm for this means she maps her everyday life, this is as fascinating as her struggle through her illness. Beutifully written a different angle on love and death, a satisfying read but keep a box of tissues by your side for the tears.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Quite moving, 19 April 2008
I read this on aeroplane and wish I hadn't - I cried! I had to sniffle away quietly at one or two places in order to not attract any attention. It is such a moving book and one I came across completely by chance. This is the first book I've read by Stella Duffy, although I do own another one and I am really looking forward to reading that.
In the beginning, the characters don't seem real, quite one dimensional. Suddenly, they become very different and I can't put my finger on what it was but I became hooked. That could well have been due to the fact that I was a captive auidence to a certain extent as I had nothing else to do for my two and a half hour flight.
It is difficult to discuss the plot without revealing what happens throughout the novel but the journey the characters go on is special. I couldn't recommend this book enough. It is touching but in such a way that it isn't wishy washy, it's quite a stark reality actually. Beautifully written, it packs a punch and holds nothing back.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Stunning Novel, 4 Mar 2009
This book is amazing, simply stunning. I don't know where to start a review exactly because I don't want to give anything away so I will try and stick to the blurb with my additional babbling along the way. Jack (a Mancunian living in New York trying to make it in TV and the news) and Cindy (a mapmaker and published writer) meet at a mutual friend's party and by the end of the evening know that they have both met someone special. What follows is the story of their relationship over the first five years moving from New York to LA and then dealing with the shocking blow when Cindy becomes incredibly ill.
The first half of the novel tells of the way relationships start and flow as they become more and more serious. The hesitations and customisations people have and make as they go through the new emotions and make room in their life for someone new, someone to become the other part of their life. I don't know how she does it but Stella Duffy writes in a way that we see all these things in ourselves and smile at them. I kept thinking as I read on `oh yes, I have felt like that' when she describes making space in your life for someone else and their habits. It's written with a delightful realism that made me empathise with the characters which only made things harder in the second half of the novel.
Oddly when Cindy moves to be with Jack from the busy city and lights of New York to the sunny skies of LA the book becomes much darker. When Cindy falls sick (and I am not going to tell you what happens) you live the moments with her. I think my journey with her was so much harder because I liked her so much (I know books aren't about characters we like but like her I did) and because someone close to me became very ill and it brought it back. I don't think I have read such a spot on description of all the emotions you go through, the questions, the anger, the sadness and the laughter apart from in Helen Garner's The Spare Room. `State of Happiness' it is all encapsulated in less than two hundred and fifty pages.
The other thing that Duffy does that I thought was wonderful is relate all of these factors with mapping. Cindy herself is a cartographer as I mentioned, we read some of the excerpts of her book and possible future novel throughout the book, and how our lives are mapped and how the routes change as we go along is a big subject of the book. It's the prose that gets me though frank yet poetic and subtle yet poignant. A friend of mine read the book just before me (and gave away the ending - tut) and summed it up in a sentence `a wonderful book, I have never read anything like it' and she was spot on.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|