I've always enjoyed mysteries. The problem is that there seem to be more cliches per page in the genre than in almost any other. Not so with journalist Bryan Gruley's first novel though, which is why I really enjoyed Starvation Like.
Gus Carpenter is a newspaper reporter who's lost his job at the Detroit Times and returned to the small, seen-better-days summer resort town in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan he grew up in to take a job as editor at the small local paper. Years earlier, Starvation Lake's beloved hockey coach died when his snowmobile accidentally fell through the lake ice, but when pieces of that snowmobile wash up one day, in the dead of winter, on the shore of a different lake, Gus begins investigating what may have actually been a murder.
Now, I'll admit we've certainly seen this sort of a setup before, but really, what hasn't been done in some form or another already? It's how a book moves on from its initial plot line that counts, and it's there that Starvation Lake parts ways with other books in the genre. Starvation Lake reads like a well told story rather than a traditional mystery. Sure, there are twists, turns, unknowns, and most of the other things you'd expect to find in a mystery, but they never feel far-fetched or cliched; each event evolves naturally, logically, and believably. The town and its surrounding areas are wonderfully written, and it's easy to jump right in and feel that you're there with everyone else. Characters have the complexity and flaws necessary to feel authentic; there are no superheros here. Bottom line is that Starvation Lake just feels REAL. And Gruley thankfully avoids (for the most part) using cliff-hangers to keep readers turning pages. I rarely burned through pages just to find out what happened and was content to let the story unfold at its own pace. That, to me, is the mark of a very fine read.
My only complaint with Starvation Lake is that parts of the end felt rushed to me. After soaking up over 350 pages of well-paced prose, to see some of the plot lines wrapped up in about a page and a half seemed out of place. For example, one major sub-plot that runs throughout the book is dispatched with a single-sentence deus ex machina. Not great, and Gruley sold himself short there.
But that's certainly no deal breaker, and you shouldn't let it keep you from reading Starvation Lake. Go back and read the second and third paragraphs of my review, because that's the stuff that has stuck with me. Starvation Lake is head and shoulders above most of its contemporaries and a great read. If you're looking for a really well written and thoughtful mystery, I can recommend it highly.