Set two years after the conclusion of Legacy of the Force and Darth Cadeus' reign of galactic terror, Outcast begins with unification negotiations between the Galactic Alliance and the Imperial Remnant. Luke Skywalker, disgraced in the eyes of the GA leadership as a result of Jacen Solo's murderous rise to power is exiled and cut off from the Jedi Order he has rebuilt. Meanwhile, Jedi Knights are experiencing psychotic breakdowns, making all Jedi potential ticking timebombs.
The Good: The pace of the story is good with short sharp chapters moving the story along nicely. As the opening book in a series it sets the scene very well. In particular the hints at how these books are going to link up with the excellent Star Wars: Legacy comic book series. We see the earliest hints of the foundation of the Imperial Knights and the Fel Dynasty for instance. The plot and subplots are fairly engaging, with the great mystery surrounding Jacen Solo's fall to the darkside keeping the reader hooked. There is one particular scene between the GA Chief of State and Luke in which they discuss the Jedi's penchant for slicing off the limbs of bad guys which raises the novel above the average. It is an interesting exploration of the Jedi's role in the Galaxy, and a wonderful explanation as to why people in the Galaxy Far, Far Away would be rather less enthusiatic about the Jedi than people in our own Galaxy.
The Bad: There are parts of this novel that simply do not stack up. Firstly Luke Skywalker's disgrace and exile from the GA is hard to swallow. Having defeated the Sith time and again and led the fight against the Yuuzhan Vong, you have to wonder just how many times you have to save the Galaxy before people start to trust you. The subplot on Kessel, involving Han, Leia and Lando seems rather a waste of time and energy. In short they spend half the book desparatley trying to save the dying planet of Kessel, enlisting the help of New Republic-era heroes like Wedge Antilles to deactivate a planet-destroying bomb. Ultimatley though Kessel is a barren wasteland owned by Lando, a man of incredible wealth already, and so we're expected to be enthralled and moved by what amounts to our heroes desparatley trying to ensure that Lando remains slighly richer than he already is. It's very hard to get excited in that context.
The characterisations are very, very weak throughout. It is almost impossible to distinguish between the banter between Jaina and Jag, Han and Leia or Ben and Luke. Not only that but Luke Skywalker appears more aggressive, light-hearted and, at times, smug than he has been portrayed in the previous EU novels. He seems a lot less mature and impressive that he did during the Dark Nest, for example, and it can be very grating.
Overall however, this is a good, if not a great, novel in the Star Wars series that sets the scene for the rest of the series. It's not as good an opening novel as the brilliant Betrayal was for the Legacy of the Force series was, however, it is a solid effort and we can only hope that without the utter rubbish of Karen Traviss' Mandalorian fanfiction that this will prove to be a good addition to the EU canon.