Most Helpful Customer Reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
A worthy attempt to convey the imagination of George Lucas, 6 May 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: "Star Wars Episode One": The Phantom Menace (Hardcover)
After 16 years, the new installment of George Lucas's space opera unveils itself onto the big screen with the largest (Dolby EX-enhanced) bang the film world has ever seen. I pity the author who, upon taking the screenplay, shooting script and 'Whills' notes from Lucas, attempts to convey the sense of majesty and epic nature of The Phantom Menace without the use of state-of-the-art CGI that so aids the storytelling on the big screen. Brooks has done a good job here, although you feel that he is never happy writing in a fantasy world that is not of his own design. The story is followed faithfully (as checked by reading through the Illustrated Screenplay) with a few deviations, although perhaps not as deep a background to the story as one would hope for in a novel based on such a rich fantasy landscape. The narrative is compelling, and I found myself finishing the book in one sitting, although two possible reasons are : 1. The simplicity of the writing style and 2. My infatuation with the subject material. All things considered, I would therefore strongly recommend this book to all fans of both the film series (it *really is* a new Star Wars episode!!), and of the sci-fi genre in general, although I am convinced that the author would have performed better without the limitations imposed by writing in such a 'franchised' universe, such as Star Wars. To anyone coming to the Star Wars novels for the first time? Yeeeeah, it's not bad....but I'd try Timothy Zahn's books first.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Far better than the movie, but really a 3.5 not 4 stars..., 28 Sep 2001
This review is from: "Star Wars Episode One": The Phantom Menace (Hardcover)
Having seen the movie and being more than a little bit disappointed in it, I was loath to read the book. But being a fan of Terry Brooks as an author, and spotting this book in a bargin bucket I decided to buy it.... and I would have to say I was glad I did, it is a good novel just a shame it was based on such a poor film. Terry has worked very hard with the material given to him to insert some grit, emotions and characters into a story that lacked those.... and I would say he has done as good a job as anyone could, whilst keeping it true to the movie. For example Jar Jar is turned from the usless muppet he was, into a scared confused alien, who is way out his depth and struggling to survive. Anakin is given a history in pod racing and also some harder edges, I just wish this could have been carried onto the end of the book.... As for the rest of the characters they are all made more believable except for the "baddies" :(. Its a great shame Terry wasn't asked to work on the screen play before the movie was made... I am sure he would have made the movie better if he had..... If you are a fan of the Starwars universe then this book is well worth reading and if you are a fan of Mr Brooks but not Starwars (thou I find that hard to comprehend) I would give this book a miss.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Meat on the bones, 29 Dec 1999
This review is from: "Star Wars Episode One": The Phantom Menace (Hardcover)
Too many cooks spoil the broth, and in the case of the reviews of this book this is certainly true. Restricted by the pre-written screenplay, Terry Brooks does an excellent job of adding depth to the film. Weighting is put on Anakin as a caring and thoughtful boy, as well as his unusual attraction to Padme/Amidala, his soon to become wife. Whilst both the book and the film are putting seeds in place for the following 5 stories, much work has been done to explain the purpose of the Jedi and their long lived history with the Sith. Almost all of the plot is tied up by the end of the book, still managing to leave you with a desperate need for what comes next. Overall a very good read. Don't expect the pod race and lightsaber fights to be as thrilling as their cinematic counterparts, but be prepared for a far deeper, more mindful story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|