When I first read the synopsis for this book, to say I was sceptical would be a huge understatement. For a while now I've felt that the brains at the Lucas Empire have been scraping the barrel of reputable story lines and this seemed to be the most blatantly ridiculous concept yet. Still, the same plot worked for Star Trek so why couldn't it work here?
Why not indeed. From the opening chapter I was hooked! The way the story kept flicking back and forwards between the two timelines was done perfectly and kept me wanting to read more. When the two finally met, the story was enthralling. It was well paced, action-packed and the suspense in the final few chapters had me totally captivated. Throughout the whole book I felt like I was there with the characters. The fact that this was done with unfamiliar characters made it even more impressive.
A nice touch was the inclusion of a well-know extinct species. There was also a slight prelude to the Legacy of the Force series, which was another nice touch. Being a `paperback only' reader, I haven't read these books yet. Nor am I a comic book reader so will never read the `Legacy' series. Still, I've kept a vague ear on what is happening in these two series and I think the way the Sith have returned behind the scenes has been handled very poorly. It would have made much more sense to use the plot from this book as a way of the Sith returning - i.e. from the past. Still, that is a different matter.
Back to this book and to the negatives. Once I had finished, I wondered why it was necessary to have the time travel aspect, especially as it has seemingly no bearing on any future series. The story would have worked fine without it. Also, I don't care if you are a Jedi or what the circumstances are; if you have just been transported 5,000 years into the future, you will be a little more shocked, stunned and interested in the state of the galaxy than these characters were. I also had the same problem with this book as I did the Darth Bane books in that, I know like all sci-fi, they have `technology well in advance of our own' but I would expect greater differences in 5,000 years than `wireless' lightsabers.
OK so my verdict. I really don't want to give it 5 stars because I just didn't want to like this book when I picked it up. The fact of the matter is I can't think of any reason not to. Paul Kemp is a great addition to the Star Wars universe in my opinion.