St Kilda: The Continuing Story of the Islands is an interesting if incomplete collection of topics and opinions about the island group. There is hardly any mention in the text about geology, climate, land or marine flora or invertebrate fauna even though those resources were readily to hand. Harman (1997) has whole chapters devoted to geology and climate, Jewell, Milner, Morton Boyd (1974) has very detailed information of vegetation including a clear map of distribution.
The book is well written and interesting to read, the many drawings, diagrams, maps and photographs leaven the text and as a whole does stand-alone reasonably well away from and since the 1995 exhibition, St Kilda Explored.
The various essays by specialists are mostly interesting and good reading but the chapter on Soay Sheep delved a little too far into the scientific minutae. Weighted towards the human history, the editor's own interests are reflected a little too closely