Here is a familiar idea for a novel: One or more long-buried bodies are suddenly uncovered. An investigation ensues, and old secrets are gradually revealed that will change people's lives forever. Peter Robinson, Val McDermid, and other popular writers have used this story line for years with great success. In "Spider Trap," Barry Maitland, a Scottish-born writer who lives in Australia, takes this generic, all-purpose premise and uses it to create a compelling tale of how the past and the present often converge with explosive results.
Detective Chief Inspector David Brock and Detective Sergeant Kathy Kolla of Scotland Yard are superbly drawn protagonists who are caught up in an ugly situation that becomes ever more horrifying as time goes by. First, two sixteen-year-old girls, Dana and Dee-Ann, are found beaten and shot through the head in a place called Cockpit Lane. The press assumes that the West Indian girls, who were well-known thieves, carjackers, and addicts, may have run afoul of some unforgiving Jamaican drug dealers. Next, a schoolboy poking around in a rail yard comes across a human jawbone. After further excavation, the police uncover the remains of three men who were tortured and executed at this site over twenty years ago. Senior Investigating Officer DCI Brock, along with Kolla, Detective Inspector Bren Gurney, forensic pathologist Dr. Sundeep Mehta, and others, team up to discover the men's identities and try to find the person or persons who killed them. Shockingly, the policemen later discover that there is a connection between the two homicide cases, even though they occurred decades apart.
As Brock tracks down witnesses, he comes across a name that makes his blood run cold: Spider Roach, "one of the most vicious and most successful crooks in South London." Spider, who is now in his seventies and ailing, was involved in fraud, arson, extortion, drug-dealing, and murder over his long criminal career. He was a ruthless predator who intimidated terrified witness and threatened to kill their families if they testified against him. His strong-arm tactics enabled him and his three malevolent sons, Mark, Ivor, and Ricky, to stay out of jail, much to Brock's chagrin. Brock ruefully tells Kathy, "Spider Roach was my big failure, Kathy." Nowadays, the Roaches own legitimate businesses and appear to have gone straight. Have they truly reformed or are they hiding their nefarious activities behind a veil of legitimacy?
Barry Maitland has created a vivid cast of characters who play out their respective dramas against the backdrop of a violent and racially-charged landscape. Brock is a lonely man who is estranged from the woman he loves, and he buries himself in his work to escape his solitary existence. Kathy has not had a meaningful relationship in years and she is on her guard when Detective Inspector Tom Reeves, an undercover cop from Special Branch, reenters her life, claiming that he wants to reconnect with her. Reeves helps Brock and Kolla gather evidence that may at long last place Spider Roach and his evil family behind bars. Teddy Vexx is a cocky hoodlum who has killed more than once with impunity; his clever and slimy lawyer finds loopholes that enable his client to remain free. Michael Grant is a Member of Parliament who was born in Jamaica in abject poverty and worked his way up to earn a prestigious position in London politics. He is an activist who goads the police to clean up London's slums and put a stop to the "evil alliance of poverty, drugs, guns, and criminal business interests operating in the district." Winnie Wellington and Abigail Lavender are two kindly women who have welcomed Jamaican boys into their homes, trying to steer them on the right path with the help of compassionate local priest, Father Maguire. As the ever more complicated events unfold, Grant, the Roach family, and the detectives are headed for an inevitable confrontation. Startling revelations and violent deaths punctuate this suspenseful and richly textured novel, which has a shocking and unsettling conclusion that proves just how elusive the truth can be.
Maitland is not content merely to write an engrossing mystery, although he has certainly done that. He creates a richly detailed picture of socially and economically disadvantaged black immigrants being preyed upon by an entrenched white criminal syndicate; of power-hungry politicians stabbing one another in the back to achieve their dubious aims; of men who abuse their wives and rely on a code of silence to keep their activities hidden; and of people whose skeletons emerge from their closets at the most inopportune times.
Laying a trap for Spider and his clan may cost the detectives their careers, their reputations, and even their lives. It is to Brock's and Kolla's credit that they are willing to risk so much and work so hard to see that justice is finally done. This is a riveting, intricate, and textured psychological thriller that demonstrates how the choices that we make help determine the paths that our lives ultimately take, for good or ill. "Spider Trap" is beautifully written, skillfully constructed, and highly recommended for fans of literate British police procedurals.