Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
73 of 76 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
God's nails - a third success!, 22 Mar 2007
In what looks like being the final book of a trilogy, C J Samson brings out long-suffering lawyer Matthew Shardlake for another mystery thriller set against the impeccably researched background of a vivid, tumultuous and colourful Tudor England.
Samson has set this trio of books in the reign of Henry VIII, and in this book the lawyer gets closer than he would otherwise care to the dangerous monarch. His old promoter and task-master, Cromwell, has already fallen out of the King's favour, being despatched before being lamented. Shardlake is therefore surprised to find him being sought out to perform more missions in the royal service.
In this book he is working for Archbishop Cranmer, the reforming Archbishop of Canterbury and pivotal figure in the religious, social and political history of the turbulent reformation times. His mission is to head to York and meet up with the King's Progress. This mighty procession of monarchical majesty is designed to impress and cow the rebellious northerners, who have only just been settled after the Pilgrimage of Grace uprising.
Shardlake, always seeking an easy life, is assured his job will simply be to help a fellow lawyer with the pleas before the King. Naturally not all goes to plan, and the unwilling lawyer is thrust into a dangerous and gripping thriller which threatens to undermine the very essence of the Tudor dynasty, the very essence of Sovereignty.
I am not usually a big fan of historical fiction. It is often used as a vehicle by poor writers to give their bland prose a splash of factual colour, a "bodice ripping thriller", as Blackadder might say. But C J Samson is very different. A historian by nature, he feels and knows the period well enough to be able to weave a rich tapestry, evoking the very essence of the times by his settings, plots, characterisations and even the conversational vocabulary.
The third book is in some ways the better of the three. It is longer, and allows a deeper development of the plot and the relationship Shardlake has with his assistant Barak and the other minor characters. The city of York is richly portrayed, and makes a change from the setting of London and the south, and he is especially sharp at the depiction of a town still smarting after the failed rebellion. If there is much of a criticism it is that it is very much more of the same. But if that has been a winning formula, that can't be much of a failing.
|
|
|
73 of 77 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An Exhilarating Progress Through Tudor Times, 27 Mar 2007
If you are already familiar with the Shardlake series you will need no second invitation to acquire this volume, as it is every bit as good as the previous two. However, if you are new to the adventures of Sansom's humane Tudor lawyer then be assured you are in for a treat. Historical whodunits are ten a penny these days, but ones of this quality are much rarer. Sansom's great skill is to evoke the England of Henry VIII so convincingly that you not only see the scenes of that ancient time but also feel them. The smells, spectacles, landscapes, characters and language of the time come truly alive and hence are an integral part of the novel's appeal. Onto this rich canvas, a complex tale of intrigue, betrayal, political rivalry, and murder is expertly woven focussing on real historical events-in this case The Royal Progress of 1541 and attendant conspiracy alongside the troubled reign of Queen Katherine Howard. Every aspect of the plot is related to the issues of the day (the author holds a PhD in History) and the set piece encounters of his fictional characters with the the era's most powerful figures are full of tension and import, consequently one learns much even as the story grips you. Yet this erudition never stifles the plot which is full of incident and moves at a cracking pace: there is none of Umberto Eco's intellectual showboating or Ellis Peters' genteel scene setting here: this is the sixteenth century in all its vibrancy, stink, and duplicity. It is also worth observing that Sansom writes well, his prose is pleasing and flows effortlessly so that a 600 plus page tome seems shorter than many half its length. In short this is a fine piece of writing which just also happens to be a thriller and one that affords the reader that very special pleasure when returning home at the end of a hard day you rub your hands and think `I can continue with Sovereign tonight'. All avid readers will understand what I mean.
|
|
|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A cracker, 17 April 2007
The book centres around the Great Progress to the North of England during King Henry VIII reign, and the activities of Matthew Shardlake, a hunchback lawyer. Ostensibly it's a bit of a murder mystery, but it's the detail, setting and characters that ring true; and the complex religious, political and class divisions. You can tell the author's PHD in history has come in handy. The other qualifications the author has (he was a former solicitor) also come in handy with the main character, who is a lawyer. This allows a fascinating insight into the world of medieval law.
It's a real page-turner, and though some parts of the murder mystery are a little predictable, there are enough unexpected twists and turns to hold your attention. Basically, I can't really fault this book. This is the most engrossing and rewarding historical novel I have read in years, possibly the best I have read since Julian Rathbone's The Last English King. The temptation when writing historical novels is often to write a swashbuckler gore-fest; something overly tongue-in-cheek; or a mystery. This sort of falls into the last category, but the research of the Tudor period is so meticulous that there isn't a sentence that rings false. I'll be reading the other CJ Sansom novels now - and if they are as half as good as this one, I won't be disappointed.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by C. J. Sansom
by C. J. Sansom
by C. J. Sansom
by C. J. Sansom
by Hilary Mantel
