Amazon.co.uk Review
Well, filmmakers should aim high, they say. And Richard Kelly shot the moon on his highly-anticipated follow-up to cult sensation
Donnie Darko, which expands the apocalyptic mood of that movie and blows it up tenfold. Set during the election season of 2008,
Southland Tales proposes a series of apparently linked events: the reappearance of a vanished movie star (
Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson), now an amnesiac; the bizarre doubling of a policeman (
Seann William Scott in two roles); the development of an energy source from ocean waves; and the presence of an Iraq War veteran (
Justin Timberlake) who seems to be watching everything, and narrating some of it. Not that the narration helps; even with voice-over (reportedly added after the film's disastrous debut at the 2006 Cannes Film Festival),
Southland Tales doesn't come close to making sense, let alone at the minimum level of dangling a carrot to lead the audience along (even
Mulholland Drive had a semblance of murder mystery to be solved, or not). The cast is loaded with
Saturday Night Live cut-ups, but only Jon Lovitz connects, and in other roles people like Sarah Michelle Gellar, Christopher Lambert, Bai Ling, and John Larroquette are utterly mystifying, by no fault of their own. In some of the musical sequences Kelly gets in stride, but it's easy to create drama in a three-minute music video, and harder to do over two and a half hours. Some top critics rushed to champion the movie, as though flying in the face of philistinism, so feel free to try out this incoherent pastiche for yourself. --
Robert Horton
Synopsis
Director Richard Kelly's follow-up to 2001's popular
Donnie Darko is a sprawling dystopian satire featuring an all-star cast and a storyline that splinters off into strange and unexpected places. The film begins with a nuclear explosion in Texas, which sparks a full-scale war between the U.S., the Middle East, and North Korea. Kelly's central character is action movie star Boxer Santaros (Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson), who is suffering from a bout of amnesia upon returning from the desert. His reasons for being in the desert are hazy, but he's hooked up with porn star Krysta Now (Sarah Michelle Gellar), and together they have written a screenplay about the end of the world. Santaros tries to prepare for the film by taking a ride with a cop named Taverner (Sean William Scott). But the cop is actually Taverner's twin brother, who is working for a shadowy group of neo-Marxists who are trying to overthrow the government. Meanwhile, a brilliant scientist (Wallace Shawn) unveils an incredible new energy source, the end of the world as predicted by the Book of Revelations draws ever closer, and Justin Timberlake (who plays an Iraqi war veteran) provides a voiceover that fills in some of the gaps. As the film builds to its explosive climax, the reasons for Santaros' time in the desert become clear, and the various strands of the plot are brilliantly woven together.
Southland Tales is packed with ideas, tangents, song-lyrics-as-dialogue (in particular, 'Three Days' by Jane's Addiction), cameos from established stars, and plenty of references to the post-9/11 political landscape. Kelly's film is bursting with imagination, and it will undoubtedly need multiple viewings for everything to sink in. Comparisons to films as varied as Richard Linklater's
A Scanner Darkly and David Lynch's
Dune are valid, but Kelly's movie inhabits a wonderful world of its own, and is a unique and inspiring piece of filmmaking.