Never will I ever be using Footprint guides again. I made the mistake of purchaisng the South American handbook in favour of Loneley Planet's South America on a Shoestring based on the strength of the reviews I read on Amazon.
I have given it 2 stars because the restaurant recommendations are good for smaller towns and villages (NOT cities -I got the feeling that the author didn't bother eating at any of the places which featured in the listings, choosing to recommend any old place only because he had to). The other star goes for mentioning which hostels/hotels have parking -a godsend for anyone travelling by motorcycle/car (which I was). No other comprehensive guidebook features this information.However, I had to borrow other travellers' Lonely Planet guides if I wanted to extract any useful information on places...
There was hardly any background/historical information on cities/sites etc, bus schedules were erroneous and the hostel recommendations were a lot worse than the recommendations you find on [...] or [...] (I ended up just using the aforementioned websites as the book was useless).
This guide is completely unbiased, so places are presented to you with little to no descriptive clues... So if time is of the essence (which it always is when you're on the road -even if you're travelling for 6 months +) you have absolutely no pointers on what places are worth visiting. I ended up wasting *A LOT* of time visiting places that are not on the tourist circuit...for very good reason... Sometimes you just want people to cut to the chase and give it to you as it is. For this, I found borrowing other peoples' Lonely Planet guides invaluable... The Footprint guide has the strange ability to make wading through broken glass in 50 degree heat sound as appealing as taking the cable car up to Sugar Loaf Mountain in Rio de Janeiro...
Needless to say I will NOT be purchasing a Footprint guide for my next backpacking trip. What a dead weight it was to lug around. In fact, after finding a motorcyclists' website where hostels with parking lots were featured, I threw the guide away thus was its usefulness...