I remember buying this album as a 16 year-old on the day it was released and playing it to death over a two-month period. 'Songwriter' came out in close proximity to John Lodge's `Natural Avenue' - another fine album - and I remember the word in the industry prior to both releases was that John's album was even better than Justin's!
But it's 'Songwriter' I'm reviewing here - an album I hadn't heard for quite a few years until I bought a copy of this CD recently. The sound is not quite as dynamic as the vinyl original in my opinion - but this doesn't detract from the quality of the songs and performances.
Listening to it again, I still love `Country Girl' - which was released as a 45 (remember them? :-)), but the melody of the first single from the album `One Lonely Room' has paled slightly for me. The song also features one of the worst couplets ever written, with Justin mourning the loss of his love and singing: `You left a car that had no wheels/You left some shoes that had no heels'. `Raised on Love' is another song with weak lyrics - they are far too soppy - but its very pretty tune compensates for this.
`Tightrope', `Stage Door' and `Lay it on Me' are outstanding tracks, the latter enlivened by Justin rocking-out on guitar - reminding everyone of what a fine player he is. And the voice! What a great set of pipes he had (and after seeing the Moodies live last year, still has!)
The title track is split into two very different, but interesting parts, although I personally think part one - with its more conventional structure - is superior to part two.
The original ten track album ended with two excellent darker tracks `Doin' Time' and the string-laden `Nostradamus', but there are four bonus tracks on this CD release.
Of the additional songs, the single `Marie' - written for his wife - is a good song, with Justin hitting the top of his vocal range. Its original `b side' `Heart of Steel' has a chorus that screams `Eurovision Song Contest' to my ears, but overall it still sounds better than I thought at the time of release. `Wrong Time, Right Place' is pleasant, but totally forgettable. Also included is a perfunctory cover of Buddy Holly's 'Learning the Game'.
The sound of this album is very different from that of the parent band, and also the lush Hayward/Lodge collaboration 'Blue Jays', but I believe any Moodies fan would be delighted to have this CD in their collection - if it isn't already in there.