7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Some lovely ideas, 28 July 2003
By kallan - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Songspinners (Paperback)
Songspinners is the story of Orial, a young woman forbidden any music because of her father's fears of the harm it might do her. But when Orial pursues a study of music in secret, manifesting an astonishing talent, and then discovers a brilliant composer fleeing religious repression in a neighbouring country, a series of events is set in motion that will change her life forever - and the lives of many others - if she can survive long enough.
I thought I should put in a brief synopsis, as no editorial reviews of "Songspinners" seem to have found their way onto this site. There's a lot to like in this book. A number of the characters are appealing or at least amusing; their varying motivations are believable and fit well into the story. Ash has a good gift for visual description, and the accounts of the Undercity and polite society in Sulien (think eighteenth-century Bath in England) are beautifully brought to life. There are secrets to be uncovered, something I always like in a book, and the resolution of the story was appropriate.
Yet I would have liked to like "Songspinners" more than I actually did. Like "Moths to a Flame", it just all felt very thin, somehow . . . I find it difficult to identify just what I felt was missing - real depth of character and setting, perhaps?
I assume this is one of Sarah Ash's earliest books. I hope her talent continues to develop from this promising beginning.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Sarah Ash's best novel to-date, 18 Feb 2008
By M. Natisin - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Songspinners (Paperback)
"Songspinners" is a novel set against the epic backdrop of Sarah Ash's expanding fantasy world where her novels "Moths to a Flame", "The Lost Child" and The Tears of Artamon trilogy all take place.
The story is one of the entwined fates of three people: Orial Magelonne,a young woman with a musical heritage forbidden to her since her mother's mysterious death; Amaru Khassian, a crippled opera composer fleeing his country pursued by a fanatical religious order; and Acir Korentan, a soldier-priest of that very same religious order who must alternately hunt and protect the composer he is sent after. In the wake of a brewing revolution that crosses international borders and shakes the foundations and beliefs of two very different countries,the three must overcome their own prejudices and disabilites as they draw closer to the truth behind the ancient culture of Songspinners.
"Songspinners" is an epic of a stand alone book, wherein Sarah Ash wrangles a cast of interesting characters and creates entire mythologies, countries and cultures with ease. Her characters are by no means two dimensional human beings, and the subjects touched upon in the book are thought-provoking, vast, and socially relevant. "Songspinners" is Ash's second novel, and is a vast departure from her first novel "Moths to Flame" both stylistically and conceptually. There were no points in Songspinners when I was tempted to say "Well, I wish she would have done THIS instead..." as I said sometimes while reading "Moths to a Flame".
Personally, this is my favorite novel by Sarah Ash. "Songspinners" even overshadows her very popular Tears of Artamon Trilogy.