I bought this book whilst staying in Scotland with my husband's 86 year old grandmother and spent many a happy hour curled up by the fire reading it. In fact, I read only little bits at a time, so that I could prolong the enjoyment! I was surprised to read the damning reviews when I logged onto Amazon to add my two cents, having just finished the book on a sunny Sunday morning.
Though I did not relate to a lot of Athill's experience - having lived a very different life myself with an avid interest in monogamous love and motherhood - I admired her for having a strong sense of self at a time when women were often forced into loveless marriages and motherhood against their better judgment, because society expected it of them. What's more, she is not afraid to write about her convictions, though she knows that they will not be palatable to everyone - there's something about women who reject mothering that people still hold deep prejudices against (especially if the woman in question enjoys carnal pleasures for their own sake - shock horror!).
I think she has been accused in one of these reviews of not having truly loved another - she freely admits at the end of her book to a regret at having 'that nub of coldness at my centre' and bravely tells the story of her shameful disinterest in her cousin's young family. This is not the work of self-interest; she willingly reveals her faults and muses on her failings. It seems that at the age of 89, however, she has come to accept herself as she is...
I found her voice warm and witty and her life, being so different to those of her generation I had heard before (realistically, how many womens' voices of that generation do we hear?), fascinating. Her frankness and honesty about her sexual choices is so refreshing and empowering for other women.
Reading it whilst staying with an 86 year old was the real clincher for me though. I found myself comparing her sharpness and alert eye for detail with my dear relative's slightly fading one. Their life stories could not be more different - one chose marriage, children, grandchildren whilst the other chose books, lovers, friends - and I found myself amazed at Athill's incredible ability to tell a story at such a ripe old age! What an amazingly alert and astute mind!
Yes, it's short, yes, she chose a different life to that we expect a woman of her age to have experienced but it is truly a pleasure to read, and I whole-heartedly recommend it.