- Audio CD
- Number of Discs: 1
- Format: Import
- Label: Jvc
- ASIN: B00005GYDE
- Other Editions: Audio CD
- Average Customer Review: 3.0 out of 5 stars See all reviews (2 customer reviews)
- Amazon Bestsellers Rank: 885,288 in Music (See Top 100 in Music)
|
Amazon.co.uk Currency Converter
Amazon.co.uk allows you to pay for your items in your local currency. Restrictions apply. Learn More. |
Product details
|
| 1. Icarus II |
| 2. When the World Was Young |
| 3. Grand Fun Alley |
| 4. Coming Dawn (Thanatopsis) |
| 5. Myriad |
| 6. Look at the Time |
| 7. Disappearing Skin Tight Blues |
| 8. Distant Vision |
| 9. Byzantium |
| 10. Not Man Bag |
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product)
|
Before I continue I should point out that I've been a fan of Kansas, and especially of their 1970s stuff, for almost 20 years. I was really excited at the prospect of hearing the first album featuring the original line up in nigh on 25 years. However, that hasn't blinded me to the fact that this album contains some of the most painfully dull music I have ever heard, from a band that can and have done infinitely better - in any of their incarnations.
I think that the main problem is that Kerry Livgren wrote the whole album away from the rest of the band and it feels like they were almost incidental to the process of recording it. To make matters worse the production is in places extremely dull and lifeless.
From my perspective there are three decent songs here (Byzantium, Look at the Time and Distant Vision) with the first two of these being the least 'Kansas' sounding of any on the album. The rest of the tracks are at best unremarkable and at worst downright tedious. The few times I've tried to listen to the album all the way through it's been a major test of will to not skip through most of the songs. I usually end up playing one of their greatest hits packages afterwards to reassure myself that Kansas actually have been a great band.
If you're a fan of old school Kansas and haven't heard this album, I recommend that you consider carefully before laying out your hard earned money on it. If you're not yet a fan, but want to check out some of their music, then I advise you to buy any other album by this truly brilliant band. Every band is allowed to produce a real lemon and Somewhere to Elsewhere is most definitely the bright and shiny yellow citrus fruit in the Kansas catalogue.
At the official Kansas website, Livgren stated that the hope was to capture the band's "original fire and vision" from the early days, and that the album would have many "familiar stylistic twists, and new twists as well." Take it from this long time fan, they've succeeded beyond their wildest imaginings.
All of the guys have obviously mended the fences that were splintered over creative and other differences nearly 20 years ago, and the renewed passion they all have for the music shows in this album. Everyone is given an opportunity to shine, from the powerhouse vocals of Greer, Steinhardt and Walsh (whose voice has never sounded better, having lost a lot of the "ragged edge" sound from previous albums), to Williams' "Meatwall" sound, on down the line. Many different influences can be heard here, including early Kansas (more obvious in "Icarus II" and "When the World Was Young"), a little Beatles (the aforementioned "Look At The Time"), Zepplin ("Byzantium"), some blues ("Grand Fun Alley") and even a bit of 50's doo wop ("Disappearing Skin Tight Blues"). Also, don't miss the hidden track about 1 minute after the final listed song; it's just the guys goofing around in the studio on a little ditty, that I can only call "Geodesic Dome Blues". My picks for radio play are "When The World Was Young" for rock/top 40 stations, and the soothing "The Coming Dawn" for the lite rock/adult contemporary outlets. This CD is not to be missed by anyone!
P.S.: If the band is reading this: Guys, my suggestion for the next album is to use the songs not used on "Somewhere to Elsewhere", throw in 5 or 6 additional songs, bring back all of the original members along with Billy Greer again to play, PLUS bring in the alumni: Steve Morse, John Elefante, David Ragsdale and Greg Robert, and really show everyone how it should be done!
There seems to much discussion about Walsh and his somewhat ragged voice. I recently went to see Kansas in concert for the tour of this album. While Walsh's voice is strained on the albums, his live performances are wonderful. What is so interesting is that songs such as "Distance Vision" work for Walsh beautifully, especially in the last stanza where he belts the lyrics with a power equal to the music. I get the impression from the CD that they left his voice all too naked through the rest of the songs. I really think the attraction of Walsh's voice in the "classic" years was that his voice was simply another instrument rather than a vocal. His ability to punch the energy in a song was similar to the unforgettable compositions from the all-too-talented band members. The technique was always complex without being complicated. In songs such as "Distant Vision" and "Byzantium", Walsh's vocal contributions are as an integral whole rather than a stand apart element. Where he falls apart (and perhaps where the songwriting on previous albums fell), is where his voice is pulled out as a highlighted element. Kansas, when at their best, are about creating music as an authorless effort. This is where I believe he has always been the most effective, even when his range was much more dynamic. I think the mixing needs to be looked at again given his range. Songs such as "Distant Vision" prove that he still has ability. However, I think that Walsh's vocals are a delicate instrument at this point and need to be handled as such.
Regarding the rest of the band, I do not want to glaze over their talent (including the non-original Greer - what a wonderful addition!), I have such respect for their ability that I simply expected no less. Phil is still one of the most under-rated drummers in the business, Robbie still has the ability to make me shiver (an what a haunting persona!), Williams still holds his guitar like a baby on stage and treats his craft with respect, and both Greer and Hope still understand that rythem can be and should be a complex element of music. And as always, Walsh's voice is best when teamed with Robbie's. I hope they both understand how well their voices work together.
Kerry Livgren, perhaps one of my favorite composers, shines on this effort throught his spirited songwriting. "Leftoverture" was released at a time of great personal self searching, and, like so many others at that time, I found in Livgren someone who poetically understood what it is like to search for answers. The answers are hard to come by and the searching can be quite painful and frustrating. The beauty of music is it's ability to show us the poetry in everyday life. It is refreshing to find through this CD that Livgren is still searching, it is simply at a much higher level.
Being a fan since 1973, I can easily recommend this album to any fan, old or new. There are areas where it approaches and even surpasses their "classic" work (Distant Vision, Byzantium, and Myriad), but there are also areas where it falls, primaily because of a mishandled vocal track. But because the high spots are so luminous, they carry the CD as a whole. After hearing the best on this album, I can see how it would be grave mistake in not having this CD in my collection. "Distant Vision", "Byzantium", and "Myriad" could have easily been on the "Leftoverture" album. These songs have those wonderful, unforgetable, uniquely Kansas melodies which you keep in your head all day long.
My love for the "classic" Kansas is that their music has the ablility to become personal rather than just entertaining. I first heard them as an adolescent teenager, and, now in my late 30's with a family and a career, the music is as fresh and meaningful as ever. I love that I will listen to Kansas out of appriciation and personal fullfillment rather than some glib nostalgic need. I still listen to my old Kansas CD because this element is missing in the current industry. Much to my delight, this new release clearly continues this all-too-rare type of musicianship. This album will become one of my favorite, probably by day's end. I would encourage the band members to continue writing and performing songs such as "Distant Vision", "Byzantium", "Myriad", and "Icarus II". This type of serious music is desparately needed in todays glib musical pantheon.
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|