Contrary to the description I found that my son could take these off but actually he really enjoys wearing them and for the first time ever now asks to have his gloves on. They pull on over or under coats and seem very snug and comfortable. They are also quite thick so definitely warmer than the mittens and magic gloves I've tried before - and it is easier not trying to feed the thumb into the right place. Also, he can still eat an apple whilst wearing these, which to him is the most important thing! They also look very cute under a big fleece hoodie :)Fingers in gloves are always going to allow them to do more, but for ease, comfort and warmth these are tremendous.