..or are all the 1 Star reviewers of this book confusing it with some other title? Yes, there are comparisons with Carver and, yes, given the period setting and events that unfold, you could make a (lazy) comparison to Rick Moody's first novel, but does that reduce it as a work in its own right? I thought for a first novel it was an assured and confident piece of writing, with a sustained mood and empathy to all the characters sustained throughout. O'Nan handles his cast with a steady hand and whilst they remain true to their natures throughout, he allows for the sudden incidences of life to ring true by not adhering to any 'three act' concepts. It's easy to imagine the events of this novel occurring in real life, along with the responses of those who survive. It's honest. It's real. The writer is prepared to face head on the sadness and despair in our lives, and fashion something powerful from that.I've read a LOT of books and I know bad writing when I see it - and this is not it. You want 'happy' books, look elsewhere...you want some truth, this is your man.
I also recommend his more recent novel 'The Night Country'