Well I wonder, could you take many other artists entire catalogue and write inciteful, stimulating and page turning biographies of each of their songs? Would we be interested in the B side fillers, the sound checks, and learn much that anyone could care about? I've a few fave artists, but even for most of those no thanks. What a bore.
But The Smiths? They are different. Every song, each media expose is worthy of highlight. Because simply they were the most important band of their generation and remain one of the icons of popular music.
Goddard's book is a gem. For Smiths fans it is an absolute must read, but be careful, you'll need to have more than a passing interest to appreciate it and, most importantly, either a large Smiths record collection, or a fat wallet and a good record shop very close by! As you read, you'll be reaching for the vinyl and CD to listen to each track as its origins, its recording and its different takes and sessions are explained. And you just must listen to each track, you'll be compelled!
That said, there's quite few tracks explained here you won't be finding on the albums and compilations, those limited to vinyl, limited edition CD releases and bootlegs, some of which will be hard to find in a hurry. So expect to feel some frustration at not being able to hear everything you read.
If you're a fan with a comprehensive collection (if not why not!?) you'll be back to The Smiths in a whole new light.
Superb.