I'm a bit torn after having read both earlier reviews as I agree in part with both. However, I'm awarding five subjective stars [how could they be anything else?] after playing this collection several times, and despite what is certainly a lessening of quality in the later sessions, it is still marvellous to hear all twenty tracks in succession without a break. The first ten are obviously the best. I noticed [did others?] that the remastering from original sources has extended the lengths of several of these 1967 tracks so that you hear extended codas at the end of some numbers and this gives them a more spontaneous quality as Sinatra and Jobim exchange little phrases and scats. Also, Sinatra's vocals are cleaner and clearer on this re-issue so that you can hear how softly he extends many phrases. It's an object lesson in hushed, romantic bossa nova. So well done Reprise. My favourites? Possibly '...Ipanema' and 'Dindi' but it's a close call. The remaining ten tracks {7 of which come from the 1971 'Sinatra and Company') are more of a mixed bag. The 7 are sung beautifully although I feel that Sinatra's phrasing is more 'poppy' rather than 'bossa nova' on these. Perhaps as a reaction to the fuller orchestrations as opposed to Ogermann's delicate backgrounds. Still, 'The Song of the Sabia' is a treat as is, to a lesser extent 'Bonita'. However, 'Off Key' ['Desafinado'} is a poor performance. It's virtually impossible to be objective when it comes to Sinatra because you have to judge him apart from other singers simply because he was the best.However, the total package deserves top stars - after all it is Sinatra.