9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Ambitious and ... excellent., 7 July 2001
It's one of the wonders of the artistic process that a single piece of work can provoke so many wildly varying responses. I fall firmly on the positive side of the fence, and am happy to recommend this as an excellent first novel. One of the book's strengths is, as the blurb says, its subversive nature; it seeks to tell a tale, rather than fit a genre or lend itself to a particular section of a bookshop. To achieve this whilst dealing with thought-provoking issues is a real coup. There's no destiny, there are no heroes, just a group of people making the best of a world which is always two steps ahead of us in the evolutionary race, making the goal of enlightenment as impossible as it ever was. At the end of the story the world hasn't been saved, the world goes on, yet the transormations made by the main characters, and the insight we gain into their world, makes the read worthwhile and pleasurable. As Homer Simpson once put it, it's just a bunch of stuff that happened.
Congratulations on a superb book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Brilliant ideas but plot very complex and characters shallow, 28 Aug 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Silver Screen (Paperback)
Having just finished Silver Screen a couple of days ago, I still have it circling through my mind, with all of its fascinating ideas and ingenious plots. There really is a lot in there to think about, and I'm very glad I read it - I'd recommend it to my friends.
Reading through the online reviews though, I find I agree with some of the comments on character development, although I didn't notice so much at the time. The characters aren't developed very well - that's not to say they're predictable, they surprise you over and over, but in a realistic way - but you don't really develop emotional attachment. But although this is a shame, I don't think it badly damages the book, simply because it is not really a book about characters or romance, but about complex ideas and plotlines.
And here comes my only other criticism - the plot IS complex. There's not just one complex manipulative web, there's at least two unrelated (those of Roy and Optinet), as well as extra complicating factors (the militant Machine Greens, and the manipulative Armour). Because of the cryptic way the plot is revealed, it can get really hard to keep straight in your head at times. At the end, when you think about any particular plot thread, you realise you sort of understand it at last, but you don't get a feeling of complete understanding (or at least IU didn't, maybe I'm just thick). You get the feeling that the author went through the list of "things they need to know", ticking them off as she went, but because there are no clear explanations of the overall picture by anybody, you can lose track a bit. All this means that, although I think it's a brilliant book, I wpouldn't recommend to the less enthusiastic readers amongst my friends, as if you read it slowly I think you'd just flounder in frustration.
But still on the whole, I think that this is a brilliant book, an amazing debut, and I'm very glad I bought it. I would strongly disagree with the earlier 1-star comments - I think to rate it that low you really have to have missed the point (although that's worryingly easy).
If you enjoy reading and like a challenge, particularly if you have never read a book about AIs and the like before, buy this book!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting Rather than Gripping, 28 Jan 2009
I do like to read authors in chronological order & am prepared to put up with first novels being perhaps not as polished as these from seasoned authors. I guess I got just that with this purchase, the plot (which I won't reveal in any detail) did cover much the same ground as other recent novels that have brain/computer interfaces and AI at the heart of the story but there was a nice twist towards the end which I didn't spot (actually, I'd like to re-read the last chapter so see again how it happened...).
At the same time, there were many passages in the book that I simply didn't understand & had to skip over. I'm not talking about moments in novels set in the future when some presently unknown piece of technology is being referred to in passing without an explanation. I can cope with this & it's quite nice in a way, because if we were transported from the early C21 to some future time, there would be things that would puzzle us. No, there were simply mention of characters' responses or actions that didn't seem to fit into the sequence of action & which didn't make sense later on either. I suspect the book needed stricter editing, or even pruning, so I'm not entirely blaming the author.
I do read good things about JR's other books so will probably move on to the next one before too long.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No