It's a shame i can't put as much effort into this review as the people who worked on the HD remastering of this collection.
If i could it would be two words long...
That'll do.
Don't get me wrong, i can play games with minor issue with no problem, i have played games where people have been complaining on the internet and i've played the game and have barely even noticed them, or they were so minor they didn't effect my enjoyment of the game. The same can't be said of this HD collection.
We all know how good HD collections can be, just look at the Metal Gear Solid Collection or Ico/Shadow of the Colossus, they look stunning on the PS3. Silent Hill deserved no less. The bare minimum standard for this collection should be, 'at LEAST as good as the original'... sadly they could't even keep to this standard.
I appreciate the effort made on the new voices, from what i have heard they are better than the originals, HOWEVER they even messed this up, they spent all that money on the new voices yet somehow allowed an obvious glitch into the game to make them unusable. Every time James stops running, which is often, there is a godawful metallic scraping noice... supposed to be an out of breath sound effect. Fortunately this glitch isn't on the original voices track.
For fear of this review just turning into a long rant and list of problems with the games I will just point out major issues. I am referring to the first 10 minutes of Silent Hill 2, Silent Hill 3 is supposedly much worse.
Fog has been thinned out to the point where you can see the edge of the game world.
Fog effects are now literally rectangle blocks of light grey floating around. I don't remember stopping in the fog in the original to laugh at the fog effects.
James moonwalks in the fog.
Framerate slows down for no reason, this is an old PS2 game for crying out loud.
Delay on attack moves.
Stretched, standard res cutscenes.
Controller input interrupted so a lot of stop start running.
Haven't ran into it yet but people report they have removed the siren/fog horn sound from the game, yes the iconic sound that everyone who has played Silent Hill would remember... they removed it, or forgot to put it in, not only that they forgot the water textures!!! Yes, really, if you want to see the worst water effects in a game look no further... sorry this is turning into a rant, i will stop here.
For a game that relies on atmosphere these glitches are even more glaring than they would be in an action game. At least they didn't add Korn to the soundtrack.
I have contacted Konami customer support but no reply as of yet, not even an announcement that they are working on fixing these issues.
I am hoping for a patch, but with the long list of problems it has it could be a while.
UPDATE
Official word from Konami, patch IS being worked on.