'The Sweeney' is rightly remembered as THE '70's British cop show. The combination of John Thaw's 'Regan' and Dennis Waterman's 'Carter', scripts by the likes of Roger Marshall, the late Ranald Graham, Trevor Preston and others, direction from the late Douglas Camfield, Jim Goddard, and David Wickes, made it a winner both critically and commercially. To see just how revered it is you only have to look at the B.B.C.'s 'Life On Mars' which was practically a love letter to the Euston Films production.
Pat Gilbert's book is entertaining and thoughtful, drawing on interviews with many of the key personnel connected with the series. I would recommend it, but with reservations. I was a bit disappointed to find the last section devoted to a lengthy episode guide. They are easy enough to find on the internet. I wonder whether any interview material had to be deleted to make room for it. Also, he is a bit hard on 'Special Branch' ( which starred first Derren Nesbitt and then George Sewell ), the Sweeney's precursor. I like both shows for different reasons. As many of the same writers and directors later worked on 'The Sweeney', it seems bizarre to knock it. 'Sweeney 2' was a boring ramble, whereas the first film was exciting ( and had Diane Keen topless ). Gilbert also indulges in an unnecessary spot of '70's bashing, some of his comments about political events in the Britain of that time could have come straight from 'The Daily Mail'. But what really made me laugh was his grousing about the lack of home computers, iPods, multi-channel television and the like. He wonders on earth how people got by without them. I was around then, Pat, and it was a case of 'what you've never had, you don't miss'!
In fairness, the book's good points outweigh the not-so good. He brings us up to date with the rumours concerning a proposed remake with Ray Winstone ( which, thankfully, has so far failed to surface ). 'The Sweeney' was of its time, and cannot be done again. Nor should anyone try.
Despite my reservations, I did enjoy this enormously, and would not hesitate to recommend it to any fan. It will make you want to see the series again, and that is the hallmark of a good T.V. related book. Perhaps Pat can next write the definitive history of 'Life On Mars/Ashes To Ashes'?