I hate to be so negative, but spectacularly bad directions combined with wind and rain gives the user a lot of time to brood, and to wonder whether the authors ever tried to read their instructions from the point of view of someone who doesn't already know where to go. Most of the directions, sooner rather than later, are alarming similar to "keep walking until you get there and then turn right" or "turn right on leaving the car park".
It is perhaps understandable that the walk around Derwentwater (the first one in the book) ignores the fact that in high water the path actually disappears (perhaps rain in the Lake District is rare). But it is really irritating to have to puzzle over such sentences, p. 18, as "Turn L where the path through the old oak wood alleviates road walking." (Is that a LATER stage than the preceding, or simply an expansion of "cross into Strutta Wood"?) Another example, p. 215: "Steps wind up to another seat on a belvedere and the road at the Glenridding village sign." Is it obvious (remember, newcomer, wind, rain) that this means actually climb up those steps? Why not say so?
I tried four of the easiest walks and completed only one as planned. In one case we got so far off track that we were seriously thinking about calling Mountain Rescue. This may mean only that I'm not an experienced walker, and that this book is intended for experienced ones. But even experienced walkers would surely be helped if (and how hard could this be?) the things with names mentioned in the instructions were also identified on the little maps? Being told to turn right at High Rake would be far more useful (p. 215) if High Rake were on the map. Call me a bluff old traditionalist ...
This would no doubt be a great book if it were beta tested: big project, I'm sure, but imagine an edition which could honestly say "directions successfully followed by walkers new to the routes." What the novice needs, especially at crucial junctures, is something like "you'll know it's the right path if you face north and can see the Black Swan Inn to your left about a mile a way; ignore the track that leads right to a sheepfold".