I read Sherlock Holmes and the Hentzau Affair by David Stuart Davies and rather enjoyed it. So I decided to give this collection of short stories a go. I have to admit that I am only half way through as I write this, but I am enjoying it. David is the editor of this book, though he does have a story or two included. Each story is by a different author, and it is interesting to see the various styles.
As the previous reviewer says, the stories are all in the familiar style rather than the more eccentric copies of the Sherlock Holmes stories. But if you are a complete stickler for authenticity you will find yourself, as I am, thinking that Holmes would not have said or done that, at frequent intervals. It isn't enough to spoil the enjoyment, but it is making me think that I should have a go at writing one! Of the ten or so stories I have read in the book so far, only one has really troubled me. It involves a trip to the North East where they take up the trail of a missing boat. The story is completely unlikely. There was no sleuthing involved, just more chance and coincidence than most people get in a life time.
That one story aside, and several instances where Sherlock seems to have developed a far greater willingness to share his logical reasoning than he ever did in the original books, this is an enjoyable read and I would recommend it to any Sherlock Holmes fan.