The game had promise and started well - spooky manor house, strange things moving in the shadows and trick doors to find and open with puzzles. BUT this soon got very old very quick - you never leave the manor house so no dusty tombs or Cairo markets as I hoped for. Just the same ten or so rooms, which you move though one way and then back out again to escape. I was glad in the end that it only took me about four hours game play to complete!
The graphics are grainy meaning its hard to tell what is what in some dark corners and it wont be long before you turn the sound off to block out Sherlock's grating voice. But don't worry, the text box will still pop up and take up half the screen whenever you try to look at something.
Some of the puzzle solutions are so obscure that you end up being glad of the built in walkthrough that means you don't have to struggle with anything for long before resorting to the clues - even though it feels very much like cheating, without doing so you would soon give up on trying to figure out the random sequence of events you need to complete to get a solution.
The story line is also a little weak and if there are any sequels, I will give them a wide berth. Broken Sword, although an older game ported over for the DS is by far superior in gameplay, storyline and characterisation - I'd recommend buying that instead.