This really is Sinatra's final masterpiece and is the sort of album he should have ended his recording career on. L.A is my lady and even 80th live offer a decent listen, however any mild or hardcore fan will know that Duets was a great disappointment. With Sinatra's voice sounding very tired, soulless arrangements and the fact that the singer were singing over pre recorded Sinatra takes, there was not a lot of dueting involved.
She Shot Me Down is the a daddy of the saloon albums that Sinatra recorded. To listen to it has the feel of a mixture between "September of My Years", a "Man Alone" and "Only The Lonely", and it has the quality to match any of the aforementioned great albums.
Sinatra's voice is in good shape considering his age and we hear Sinatra singing in the lovely bass range of his voice with offers immense warmth and smoothness. Whilst flexibility and agility in his voice is lost, this is only noticeable over long phrases or dynamically loud phrases, and if anything this strained quality adds to the emotion of the album. This is Sinatra's most emotionally sung album, and he takes emotion in a song to a new level, the only stage further is practically crying the songs as we hear on the last four bars of "One For My Baby" off of the Duets album. If you listened to "Bang Bang She Shot Me Down" you could almost be fooled into thinking Sinatra sang this is the late 60's as is the richness in his voice. His phrasing his flawless and among the best I have ever heard on a Sinatra record.
The Star tracks off of this album are the immensely under appreciated "Long Night" and "Hey Look No Cryin", I also have a special fondness for "Thanks for the Memory" and "I Loved Her". Without question the star track is the final medley of "The Gal Who Got Away/It Never Entered My Mind". I frankly believe this be one of the finest recordings of the 20th century across any genre of music. The beautiful arrangements and singing are enhanced by the sheer nostalgia of these immense standards and who it is singing them.
Overall Jenkins and Sinatra work their magic once again and create an album of the highest quality. The concepts, nostalgia and what this album represents goes hand in hand with the sheer musical quality that is produced.