Well, I'll admit it... I had never heard of the Sentry before New Avengers came out. What can I say? My comic book reading had kind of lulled when this title came out back in 2000/2001. More the fool me!
The Sentry is the story of a man who believes he was once a great super hero, but can't remember how he's ended up as a middle aged, alcoholic agrophobic. Something's gone seriously wrong with Bob Reynold's life! But what?
And that's the key to this book... who is the Sentry, and why does no-one remember him? It's a super hero mystery, and by god, it's a real page turner! By the end of the first part I had convinced myself that this was the new Watchmen. Jae Lee's superb art increase the sinister and mysterious tone set by Paul Jenkins expert script to the point where you feel like something really bad is going to happen if Bob can't work this out.
This book collects Sentry 1-5, Sentry/Fantastic Four, Sentry/Spiderman, Sentry/Hulk, Sentry/X-men and Sentry Vs The Void.
Sentry 1-5 Lay out the plot and throw down the questions. It's like a countdown to oblivion, and I actually found myself putting the book down to save it, then 30 seconds later picking it up, opening it, then putting it down again...
Then we get to the flashback stories featuring other characters from the marvel universe as they start to remember who the Sentry is, and this is where it all falls down. The Fantastic Four issue is just plain rubbish. The artwork is horrible (Jae Lee steps of for these stories) and cheap, and the story is hacknied. I know this is kind of the point, as it's trying to take us back to the Silver age in the Marvel Universe, before things got gritty and serious, but after 5 issues of excellent "gritty and serious", it just doesn't work. Having said that, it's better than the Spiderman story, which I don't even want to talk about. Ugly.
Thank heavens for Bill Sienkiewicz and Mark Texeira who handle the Hulk and X-Men issue respectively. The Hulk issue in particular is superb, showing a different side to the Hulk... and like I was saying earlier, that feeling of impending oblivion starts creeping up on you again.
Sentry Vs The Void is where Jae Lee comes back to round things off, but the tension's relaxed a little bit now because of the big pause in the narrative, and I think they could have done with spreading this part out a bit longer to get us back into the swing of things, and to really get those answers.
I so desparatly want to be afraid of the Void, like every character in the Marvel Universe, but we really don't know enough about him, and the ending lacks weight... it's still a good ending, but it could have been soooooo good, and I can't help but feel a little sad at what could've been the best comic experience ever.
This collection also includes all of the interviews with Stan Lee, and all of the publicity surrounding the launch of the title (Marvel conned everyone into thinking that the Sentry really was a lost superhero created by Stan Lee before the Marvel Universe started), and as glad as I am that it's all included, I wish they'd laid it out better, so you could follow the publicity with the story, as it's meant to add to the reader's involvement in the comic. As it is, It's all bunged in the back. We should have had an introduction, as well as an afterword.
Any way, minor gripes aside, you should buy the Sentry, it really is very good... But it could have been the best.