| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Amazon.co.uk Trade-In Store
Did you know you can trade in your old books for an Amazon.co.uk Gift Card to spend on the things you want? Visit the Amazon.co.uk Trade-In Store for more details. |
Product details
|
'Sparkling and enjoyable'
(New Statesman )Intelligent, provocative and accessible, THE SELFLESS GENE offers the prospect of a reasoned dialogue between faith and scientific study, and a reconciliation of what are popularly seen as two opposing worldviews. (20091126)
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A masterpiece.,
By
This review is from: The Selfless Gene (Paperback)
As an interested, but largely naive and uninformed, observer of the immensely profound issues which Charles Foster addresses in The Selfless Gene,I found this book immediately accessible, brilliantly argued and, most importantly, completely understandable. The subject matter lends itself very easily to impenetrable arguments and zealotry but Foster avoids both of these pitfalls. Anybody, and I mean anybody, who is interested in the creationist vs Darwinist argument should read this book. In fact, in my opinion, this book should also be on the required reading list of every Theology course in the country.
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A heady forensic roller-coaster through Darwin territory,
By Samston (London) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The Selfless Gene (Paperback)
A new book from the pungently poetic pen of the peripatetic polymath, Charles Foster, always warrants the cracking open of a new case of bubbly, and this latest book is no exception. As with his earlier books, The Jesus Inquest: Myth or History? and Tracking the Ark of the Covenant: By Camel, Foot and Ancient Ford in Search of Antiquity's Greatest Treasure, the reader of The Selfless Gene hitches a ride on a heady forensic roller-coaster, this time on a timely field trip through Darwin territory to wrestle with the seemingly intractable challenges to theology and theodicy posed by evolutionary theory and the gigantic global graveyard on which all life depends. Exasperated by the reductionism of Dawkins et al, and even more so by the stubbornly wooden literalism of the creationists who read Genesis as they would a Haynes workshop manual, Foster charts a course through stormy waters, ducking none of the difficult questions: animal pain, sub-optimal design, the deployment in the natural world of the British Leyland approach to new model design (the irrepressible raiding of the spare parts bin to produce something that, after a faltering start, just about works, after a fashion....), the existence of disease and predation long before man came on the scene, etc. etc. It's an immensely stimulating read for expert and layman alike - the reader's brain goes into overdrive without ever getting stuck in a quagmire of detail (there is no lack of detail, but it never seens superfluous or gratuitous). The delightful equation and juxtaposition of Kentucky and North Oxford (A Tale of Two Cities and two Bigotries), the lacerating but never quite uncharitable humour, and the sense of wonder and awe make this book as pleasurable as it is engaging. The reading of the explosion of the Upper Palaeolithic in the light of Genesis 1-3 (and vice-versa) is compelling and possibly ground-breaking. I guess one of the reasons why Foster's writing is so refreshing is that it's clear from his bio and website that his interests are both deep and wide-ranging. As a vet, lawyer, explorer, archaeologist, travel-writer, hunter and beer-drinker, gazelle immobiliser, mammal slayer and mammal mender, he is thankfully free of the myopeia of excessive specialisation that so blights our age and is the enemy of both wisdom and fun. Highly recommended.
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great overview - but narrow view of God,
By Tom Hedge (London) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The Selfless Gene (Paperback)
Overall a first class book which I strongly recommend and which I will certainly put on a list of books to give to friends. The author's objective was to address
"(a) Did God create? (b) If yes, what does the creation and the mechanism of its generation tell us about God's nature?" In chapters 1-5 he does a brilliant job on point (a) of describing and dismantling the arguments of Dawkins and the Creationists. He demonstrates how they are bound by a belief in the inconsistency of the God and evolution which is grounded neither in the Bible nor in science. Therefore a belief in God and a belief in Darwinian evolution are easily reconcilable. In chapter 6 he gives a detailed account of how even a detailed and textual interpretation of Genesis is perfectly compatible with evolution. It is only an extreme form of stunted literalism which causes problems. This is an excellent chapter for readers who are troubled by some apparent inconsistencies because they have a form of religion which is based upon a close study and interpretation of the Bible. The author gives the impression his form of religious faith is of that type. The discussion of the "selfless gene" ie the potential role of altruism in evolution is very interesting but a thought-provoking hypothesis rather than a tight scientific argument. The importance is so that we can reconcile evolution with morality. The chapters I found disappointing were chapters 7-9 in which he narrows the discussion down to a very particular form of Christian God which is basically Anglican. For example he says "Christians do not believe that when they die they go to heaven" which means he is defining "Christian" to exclude most people that think they are Christians. He debates at length the theological problem of how to resolve the belief in a Christian God which is "Good" with a world which contains pain and suffering. But this subject while interesting has very little to do with evolution as the problem significantly pre-dates Darwin and even Creationists accept limited natural selection. His frame of reference for this is entirely Biblical which I am sure fits his personal religious beliefs but is of much less interest to the general reader if their religion is not exactly the same as his. I would have found a broader discussion based upon comparative religions and how they may have conflicts with evolution to be of much greater interest. So a glorious 5 stars for part (a) and only 3 for part (b). But well worth the time and the money for the first 5 chapters.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews |
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
|