The peculiar thing about Hill's career is that he wrote five books of poetry from 1950 to 1995, and has written six or seven more since 1995. The Selected is a good introduction to Hill's occasionally sloppy and prosaic later work: the poems included are a lot better than those left out; it turns out that there were, after all, some good poems in Hill's atrocious volume "Speech! Speech!" The Selected is a much more painless introduction to later Hill than the original volumes: with earlier Hill, the situation is somewhat different. A lot of good poems from "King Log" and "Tenebrae" -- poems with passages like this --
The pigeon purrs in the wood; the wood has gone;
dark leaves that flick to silver in the gust,
and the marsh-orchids and the heron's nest,
goldgrimy shafts and pillars of the sun.
...
`O clap your hands' so that the dove takes flight,
bursts through the leaves with an untidy sound,
plunges its wings into the green twilight
above this long-sought and forsaken ground,
the half-built ruins of the new estate,
warheads of mushrooms round the filter-pond.
("Idylls of the King")
have had to be left out, mostly, no doubt, because of a lack of space. This was unfortunate and somewhat avoidable as including the first five books entire would have added fewer than 100 pages to this book.
Hill's combination of lyricism, nostalgia, obscurity, religion, violence (he wrote a famous essay called "Poetry as menace and atonement"), and grumpiness is probably not everybody's cup of tea, but most people interested in poetry _as language_ will find something to enjoy in his work. William Logan remarked that Hill has his finger on the pulse of English more than any other living poet; I'd go further, and say that no 20th century poet has used the language with such consistent authority and richness:
Distant flocks gaze into limestone's half-light.
The full moon, now, rears with unhastening speed,
sketches the black ridge-end, sheds thin lustre
downward aslant its gouged and watered scree.
("Orchards of Syon")
or this, from the last poem in the book:
the humming bird that is not
of these climes; and the great
wanderers like the albatross;
the ocean, ranging-in, laying itself
down on our alien shore.
("Broken Hierarchies")
This much-delayed American edition of Hill's Selected Poems -- it came out in Britain in 2007 or so -- doesn't include the poems in his latest book, _A Treatise of Civil Power_, which came out after the British _Selected_; a few of the poems in _Treatise_ -- "Masques," "The Peacock at Alderton," "Before Senility," "Citations I" -- will eventually be part of the Hill canon. That said, however, there is very little in this book that isn't worth reading, and it will hopefully get Hill at least some new admirers.