Got a kid who reads well but is afraid to open any book that a) doesn't have pictures; and b) has more than 100 pages? Well, The Secret Order of the Gumm Street Girls will cure him/her of that!
Take 4 girls who distrust each other, introduce some magical shoes, a sinister woman trying to steal the shoes, some Wizard of Oz mythology, and a magical piano teacher with 2 talking dogs, and you get the makings of a great story. The girls aren't always as well defined as they should be, and the plot is a little confusing in places (hence 4 stars instead of 5), but that won't make a bit of difference to most readers. There's mystery, excitement, magic, danger and humor enough to keep all but the most stubborn readers entertained.
Best of all, The Secret Order of the Gumm Street girls is told in an easy, humorous style, with great line drawings on every page (much like those in Roald Dahl's books)--a magic formula that makes kids forget it's over 400 pages long. My daughter (9 years old) read 200 pages in the first 2 days--and that's 100 pages more than she's ever read in any book!
So forget about whatever weaknesses the book has. Ms. Primavera has more than made up for them by creating an exciting, humorous and ultimately moving novel that fills the wide gap between Judy Moody and Harry Potter.
This is a must-have for any school or library.