2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
To Mars And Back Again, 29 July 2001
By A Customer
Paul J. Macauley is a fascinating writer, not only for his ideas and characters but also for a certain rough-hewn quality that allows a glimpse his book's internals. TSOL is his most polished novel so far and only really suffers from a sudden ending which could have done with an epilogue of some kind.
As I was reading I had a certain irritation with the heroine, Mariella Anders, she seemed too intelligent yet occasionally plain daft and ,dare I say this, had too much background. In fact Macauley plays a deft game of giving us interesting snippets of her past throughout the book. This can be annoying but as the book finishes it really pays off.
I also felt the sex balance was off-kilter intially but with the Firstborn Crisis taken into account and a neat plot twist at the end I realised all the characters had to be just as they were. Paul has made a tight thriller out of complex questions of scientific ethics and as ever he points the way ahead for SF. Bravo PJM.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb intelligent Sci-fi thriller!, 3 Feb 2001
This is one of those books you just can't put down. A feasible premise opens this political - science fiction thriller (techo-thriller if you will)and doesn't let go until the final pages. I for one didn't 'suss' out how this story would end and I think that any reader of this book will be kept guessing until the end.
Is there life on Mars? Not the bug eyed variety but a Bacteria type that reacts on Earth after an 'accident' that leaks into the worlds oceans. A race against time to find out the source and way to stop it leads Dr Anders on a once in a lifetime trip to the red planet. I found the chapers set on mars some of the best literature based on the Red planet.
This is a great thriller - and a superb piece of modern science fiction. Intelligent, persuasive and so very readable. This deserves to be a best seller for Paul Mcauley and the publisher - much better than some of the well known 'pulp' that finds a long run at the top of the Bestseller Charts.
BUY THIS BOOK - YOU WON'T BE DISAPPOINTED!!!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mars attacks!, 8 Mar 2004
This review is from: The Secret of Life (Paperback)
Mars has always held a fascination for science fiction writers, but with a recent slew of books on the subject is there anything new to do with the Red Planet? Paul McAuley (what happened to the 'J'?) has hit on a great central idea for The Secret of Life by inverting H.G. Wells' War of the Worlds - instead of the Martian being infected by a human virus, here the Martians themselves are the virus that accidentally infects Earth's biosphere. While the idea is good however, the execution is a little hit and miss.
The novel starts well, in classic hard-sf style, as biologist Mariella Anders learns about the Martian 'oilslicks' spreading throughout the world's oceans, and prepares to fly to mars to identify the source of the infection and find a cure. While the traditional weaknesses of hard-sf are apparent - pages of scientific jargon that the author expects all the readers to be instantly familiar with (in this instance I doubt that anyone without at least an A-level in biology will understand the more technical passages) and the preference of intellectual ideas over emotional content leading to a rather dry textbook feel at times - the central mystery is strong enough to keep the reader hooked.
Unfortunately once Mariella obtains a sample of the Martian lifeform things go downhill as the novel steers firmly into techno-thriller territory. Following an unconvincing D.I.Y. Earth re-entry after stealing a Chinese spacecraft, Mariella spends the last third of the novel on the run from the various shady characters with a vested interest in the Martian biotechnology.
There's some good arguments made regarding big business co-opting of science, but ultimately the momentum of the novel is lost as we go into sub-James Bond territory (stopping off for some unnecessary continuity ties with McAuleys' novel Fairyland), while the various inhabitants of McAuley's 'invisible country' seem over-familiar from previous novels.
Crucially, apart from one section where a Chinese expedition gets accidentally infected, there's no sense of threat from the Martian lifeform itself, with no sign of the 'claustrophobic tension of Alien' promised by the cover blurb. For all that this Martian biology may overrun the Earth itself the threat remains an abstract intellectual one, and a real missed opportunity when compared to Ian McDonald's similar alien threat in Chaga.
The Secret of Life contains some great ideas, but as a novel this is a rather dry intellectual exercise, lacking in drama or emotion. An interesting read, but not a particularly enjoyable one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No