Where First Person was a series of essays between squabbling scholars, Second Person is a refreshingly focused review of storytelling and role-playing. Instead of authors inventing new phrases in each essay we get a real grounding in the foundation of role-playing games: their origins (Mona), theory (Costikyan), and all of these elements put into practice (George R.R. Martin, among others).
The book is divided into three sections, covering tabletop systems, computational fictions, and real worlds. Tabletop role-players will recognize the heavy hitters here: Ken Hite, the late Keith Herber, Jonathan Tweet, Rebecca Borgstrom, Nick Montfort, John Tynes, and more. Throughout are short essays detailing what worked and what didn't, from interactive fiction to Call of Cthulhu, Alternate Reality Games (ARGs) to The Howard Dean for Iowa Game (yes, really).
Second Person goes a step further in including three tabletop role-playing games: Puppetland by Tynes, Bestial Acts by Costikyan, and The Extraordinary Adventures of Baron Munchausen by Wallis. It's unlikely this book will be used as an actual gaming reference, but the inclusion of these three games is enlightening as the essayists put their words into practice.
Second Person isn't afraid to stretch boundaries, sharing insights as diverse as the Prince of Persia and the adventure gamebook Life's Lottery, from Martin's collaborative Wild Cards stories to the interactive fiction Planetfall. As you read through each essay a pattern emerges, of authors trying to tell stories, frustrated by the limits of the medium, and adjusting to adapt. It's an education of showing rather than telling. Tynes' essays are particularly illuminating. His thoughts on escapism neatly sums up the plight of fantasy gaming today.
With dozens of essays on the evolution of storytelling games and three role-playing games to boot, Second Person is an important work that even has replay value. A must have for any game scholar.