I seemed to have a pair that should not have come through a quality test. I chose size large, and the gloves were quite small (my hands are size 8,5). But that was only an issue for the right hand. That inner glove was way smaller than the outer glove. The left hand was still alright, although a bit tight, but the right hand was unbearably small inside, while there was still lots of room left in the outer glove. When you consider that my left hand is bigger than my right, there was definitely something strange going on with these gloves. That's why I didn't want them replaced.