I really have big trouble chosing how many stars to give it. I'm a metal fan. I discovered Type O, black metal and gothic thanks to HIM. They made me. And now, 11 years later, 9 after the horror of 'Deep Shadows and Brilliant Highlight' - THIS!
The metal fan in me, who was hoping for something at least as heavy as the kinda unfinished 'Venus Doom', and as gloomy and romantic as the 'classic' HIM stuff, got a slap in the face. Ouch!
But since I want to review it properly, lets be objective. I know many metal fans who appreciate all sorts of music, even if it's not heavy. So, one just should approach it more maturely, not with if-it's-not-metal-it's-bad sort of thinking. And this album indeed borders with pure (but still weird) pop-music. But it IS good. It is so damn freaking good.
The memorable melodies which we so much missed in 'Venus Doom' are back. The rock'n'roll guitar solos of Mikko Lindtrom are still that perfect (even if not so audible). On the whole it's very 80s and quite fast. As Metal Hammer correctly advices, DO LISTEN TO IT WITH HEADPHONES. Seriously.
The album is perfectly produced. The lyrics border with the genius, the best ever from HIM. There's no need to speak of each song - Hammer did that perfectly!
What I don't approve is the inside cover. We got to know that the band members have not been together at the appropriate time in order to make a decent photoshoot. Such excuse is rather lame. If you can't find several spare hours to shoot copule of snaps for something that you live off, then I don't know what for.
And since I'm talking about the deluxe edition (which is really far more worth than the single CD kit), I'll just add that I have no words to describe the acoustic album. I noticed that the disappointed metal fans, like me, found peace with this one. It is pure melancholy. Dense, concentrated Finnish melancholy (and a few owls). Precisely what the album lacks. That is the CD to behold.
Personally I accept 'Screamworks' (by the way, kudos to the master behind the mike - he's in a class of his own in this one) and 'Venus Doom' as the two sides of one coin. Not only because I know the story behind the lyrics and so. They're like ing and yang precisely. Really a good album. Not heavy, but other than that - perfect.