Rating: 6/10
Best tracks: `Schooldays', `I'm in Disgrace', `Education', `The First Time We Wall in Love'
The last of the Kinks' musical theatre-minded albums, despite still being rooted in the structure of the band's last few albums, nevertheless points towards the conventional approach they would adopt from the Sleepwalker LP onwards. There's a few songs here which could have been straight-up radio-friendly singles, songs like the warm and nostalgic `Schooldays', the rocking `The Hard Way' and the almost Steely Dan-ish `No More Looking Back'. Then again, there's also the campy, retro boogies of `Jack the Idiot Dunce' and the 1950's dream-pop of `The First Time We Fall in Love', which are more in line with the stage musical atmosphere Ray was so besotted with. Well, I say dream-pop only partly in the case of the latter song- the second half of the song, where our character falls out of love, is a little darker and spiteful. The character in question is Mr. Flash, one of two rivals from the band's ambitious Preservation production a few years back. Here we go back in time to Flash's schooldays, where a scandalous incident led to ritual humiliation for the young lad.
The story featured in this album isn't amazingly riveting, certainly not as thought-provoking or fascinating as the one for the underrated A Soap Opera, and the latter run of songs aren't too hot - `The Hard Way', `The Last Assembly' and `No More Looking Back' are pretty average, but the album certainly kicks off in style with the afore-mentioned `Schooldays', which is definitely the best thing here - the playing is warm, quite similar to what Elton John would do with `I Guess That's Why They Call it the Blues' years later. I hated school myself, and it's a testament to the strength of the song that I can hear a line like `Schooldays were the happiest days' without retching. `Jack the Idiot Dunce' won't be for everyone, but it's a cool 1950's rock and roll pastiche, while `Education' is a multi-song suite that certainly has its moments, while `I'm in Disgrace' rips off The Who's `I Can't Explain' riff with gleeful style. `Headmaster' is pretty good too and one of the more overtly narrative themed songs. Overall though, the album seems to be too top-heavy in terms of song quality and plot. The album sets the scene effectively and then throws in the vital moment of drama and then starts to wind down almost immediately, leaving one feeling short-changed and underwhelmed. Interestingly, the album is due for a film adaptation - let's see how that one works out....