Well, I get there in the end. I've only just read this - in June of 2009 - and yet it came out in October of 2007. To be honest, I'm stunned that mine is the first review of this trade paperback as it is, to be honest, rather bloomin' excellent!
I've got back into reading comics after a bit of a hiatus, and though I generally have a love of dark superhero fare, SF or strange road trip stories like Garth Ennis's Preacher, I've found myself led to Scalped by a growing appreciation of rather excellent crime comics that has followed in this order:
Punisher: Welcome Back, Frank > the
Punisher MAX series > the
Criminal series > Scalped.
Scalped, like those that led me to it, is nicely complex and full of rich characterisations. The basic plot is of a late 20s Native American called Dashiell Bad Horse who, after 15 years of absence, returns to the reservation he grew up on. Here he ends up working as a semi-corrupt cop for a local Chief and man of money and influence called Red Crow (though, of course, that's only one small element of the whole story).
This is a tale full of drugs and violence and passion and anger and subterfuge, and has twists and turns of plot that keep you in great suspense. I gobbled up this first volume in a day and immediately ordered the next (currently available) three online.
One of the things I love about this volume as well, is the insertion of flashbacks (a la Lost) whereby we learn much more detail and history of many of the characters. Now, one could just learn that from boring exposition, as chatted away by any of the characters, but the beauty of flashbacks is that the writer and artist allow us to become time travellers and take us back to those moments so we can experience them as they happened.
Jason Aaron is a new young writer (and it's no surprise that the great Brian K. Vaughan of
Y: The Last Man fame gives a glowing introduction to this volume) who obviously has a great talent and a great future ahead of him. Apart from the Scalped series he has also written
The Other Side, which I have on my yet-to-read graphic novel shelf, and I am made all the more excited of that future reading after experiencing this marvellous first volume of Scalped.
And, of course, all comics are a joint venture between writer and artist, and it is fair to say that R. M. Guera's art is perfect for this story. It has a grimy and dirty flavour to it which also has moments of pure delicate sensitivity where scenes are nuanced perfectly and characters expressions are made so very real.
I can't recommend this enough. Much has been said of it's similarity in writing quality to the Sopranos, but I've never watched that so I cannot comment on that fact. But if you love a decent crime comic (such as
100 Bullets or Criminal), or just enjoy a well scripted and darkly involving drama, then you may well take to this as much as I have.