I have to say that I was keen to read a medieval mystery and was encouraged by the long series of Paul Doherty's books - so I decided to give the first in the Hugh Corbett character range a try.
I have to say that this is Paul's first book in this series and there may have been teething problems - but unfortunately too many for me to return back to them.
The premise of the story is good - an apparent suicide to be investigated, the church, devil worship, a secret sect, conspiracy and treason against the King. The problems begin as the actual plot of the story pans out. It is very very disjointed. We have a LOT of emphasis on the historically accurate backdrops (places, streets, clothes, food) and a very rushed story with the characters - using many random cliché's such as relaying to the reader that the main character has discovered something integral to the plot but not actually revealing what this is for another few pages...why? It only serves to annoy not to encourage reading - especially in such contrived scenes that basically did not leave any room for guess work - I had the main villain (easily, folks) figured out by chapter 4 and the author does not reveal this revelation until the end (of course) in an embarrassing build up.
I also felt the actual execution of the novel was extremely poor. On one page alone the character had moved to around 3 different places in London and the author tried to cram in a series of events that occurred in each. It was like watching a film on fast forward.
The characters had potential but again their development was rushed, and where you were given a background to induce some kind of empathy this was lost really as the book delved into another "well researched" historical tangent.
It is clear that Paul Doherty is a researcher in this field and has a definite passion for it - he even added an authors note at the end saying that "some of the characters actually existed" - wow, I only hope their true story was better executed than this.