This was one of the occasions when I decided to support my local bookshop rather than buying online, but I soon regretted not checking the reviews before choosing. The book sounded intriguing, set on the Scottish coast which I love, but although the theme is interesting - great-aunt with dark secret from past living alone in old house set into cliff, great-niece visits, truth eventually revealed - somehow the story never quite seems to gel.
It has its moments and there are some lovely descriptions but much of the conversation seemed stilted and unnatural. It would no doubt sound worse if read aloud.
The author clearly feels strongly, quite rightly in my view, about the over-fishing of our seas and the wasteful discards, when millions of fish are thrown back dead into the sea every year as a result of fishing policies. But the long `speeches' on the subject that punctuate the conversation of Ben, a young marine researcher, are best reserved for the soapbox and sit uncomfortably within the context of a novel.
All in all, a disappointment and not a book I'd recommend.