8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Nicely packaged, but....., 29 Sep 2007
This review is from: 'Salem's Lot (Hardcover)
I must start by pointing out that the 3 stars awarded here are not for the novel itself; it still remains a classic vampire tale and a great contemporary reworking of Bram Stoker's Dracula. If you haven't already done so, read it, especially on a cold autumn night when the wind's blowing and the trees outside are rustling. As King himself implores in the new introduction here '...why don't you turn off all the lights except for the one over your favourite chair?-and we'll talk about vampires here in the dim.'
No, the 3 star rating depicts my disappointment in this actual so-called 'special edition.' When The Stand was re-released in the early 90's we were treated to an extra 400 pages of text which were originally excised before the original publication as King was a relatively untested author and those extra pages would have made the cost of publication, binding, etc, prohibitive. When we were finally able to read the novel in it's 'uncut' form we were shown a whole new character arc with a new journey, as well as additional experiences and backgrounds of already well-loved characters. The chance to experience Salem's Lot all over again in the same light was too good to pass up.
But that's not what we get here. The novel is presented in it's original form with the promised 'previously unpublished fifty pages of material' added on afterward, a bit like the extras on a DVD. Why some of this wasn't included in the book is a mystery. In these pages we find Barlow's (originally called Sarlinov) daytime guardian is an army of rats, resulting in a much more gruesome death for Jimmy Cody; an extremely disturbing sequence involving a vampire baby; a longer sequence in which our heroes travel through the Lot staking and exposing vampires to the sun, and various additional character background pieces. Some of the scenes are alternate takes on events: Callahan meets a different fate here than in the book- which would have left a major story arc in The Dark Tower books turning out very different!- and the final showdown is slightly different. As interesting as these pages are I personally don't interpret this to be 'the novel as the author intended'. It would appear that we've already had that for the last 30 years!
It's a nice touch to include the connected short stories 'Jerusalem's Lot' and 'One For The Road', previously only available as part of the 'Night Shift' collection, the latter being a wonderfully creepy sequel to the main book and the former a prequel of sorts, but the inclusion of a half-dozen arty black & white photos which bear little relevance to the text does not make an 'illustrated edition' in my humble opinion. Some drawings or paintings by previous King collaborator Berni Wrightson would have been so much more entertaining and appropriate...
So, a beautifully produced and bound hardback package for those who are unfamiliar with the town of Jerusalem's Lot, or for those who only know Father Callahan from The Dark Tower and want to know his back-story and origin; otherwise it's only for those who must have everything that Stephen King has published. You know who you are. And, dammit, I'm one of you!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Stephen King at his best, 7 Feb 2010
This review is from: 'Salem's Lot (Hardcover)
In my humble opinion this is the definitive vampire story of the twentieth century. I remember seeing the tv series as a youngster and it scared the **** out of me but also instilled in me a love for vampire lore that remains to this day. On the down side it was hard to read the book without seeing Ben Mears as David McCallum although I was suprised to read the description of the vampire as nothing like the Nosferatu type creature portrayed in the series. I don't see this as a reworking of the Dracula story at all. Dracula is a much more tragic character inspired more by love than greed. King's vampire plans to take over a whole town, the like of which we never really see again until the advent of '30 Days of Night'. King's vampire are evil ravenous beasts not pretty boys with no teeth or Southern gentleman, this is horror writing at its best. I must agree with the previous reviewer however that the book does not give value for money. I have a copy of 'The annotated Dracula' and hoped that this would be in the same vein. I agree that the pictures add nothing and the extra pages are even described as 'deleted scenes' in the style of a dvd. If that was the road that the publisher wanted to go down then the text should have been re-inserted in context and released as 'The Director's Cut'. I should also warn you that this is also not a book for the limp-wristed, its about three inches thick and must weigh 3lbs, I read it in bed until my arms couldn't hold it up any more!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
salems lot, 17 Oct 2006
This review is from: 'Salem's Lot (Hardcover)
This was the first Stephen King book i have decided to read and it was one of the best horrors i have read by any author in recent years. it was not overly scary but still had a chill about it.
although a gripping read it did have a very predictable ending which let the book down. a good read for any King fan, it kept me entertained.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No