I always hate giving less credit for albums when the only reasons I can justify it is by saying 'because I don't like the music as much.' However, with A State of Trance (ASoT) 2008, I have 4 previous compilations to compare to.
First of all, in my review I gave ASoT 2007 five stars, which with the benefit of hindsight was very generous. Four at a push. ASoT 2008, however, has dipped lower than this one even still, which is a real disappointment.
For a start, I feel Armin van Buuren, trance legend that he is, did not mix this album to his usual perfection - whether this is just because of the choice of tracks, also disappointing, is not clear. Usually I can picture a sunkissed journey with ASoT albums, but not this time. It was quite disjointed in places.
I kept waiting and waiting for that killer track, one that really sparked the album into life - but it never came.
One positive in comparison to ASoT 2007 was the toning down of the vocals. Some reviewers expressed their annoyance at the almost 'cheesy' vocals on ASoT 2007, which to an extent I agree with now (although I didn't at the time, for some reason). This has largely been eradicated in ASoT 2008, with far more songs being purely instrumental. However, there are so many that lack the typical passion we are used to with ASoT. Armin's choices are all a bit 'safe' it you like.
If comparing ASoT 2008 with (in my opinion) the best of the ASoT's, 2005, there is a huge difference. ASoT 2005 was just sensational, with great track after great track (with that wretched Ballerina being the exception). Of course, you could argue that ASoT 2008 is less good simply because the music back in 2005 was of better quality, but if you look (and I hate to do this, but I think it's necessary) at Anjunabeats 6, also just released, that contains a brillant collection of music. So unless Above & Beyond signed the rights off to every good trance track in existance, Armin has just made bad choices.
Which leads me to my conclusion - if you're looking for really good, diverse and creative trance, then I suggest Anjunabeats 6.
Don't get me totally wrong - ASoT 2008 is still OK, with the likes of Guiseppe Ottaviani, Stoneface & Terminal and Andy Moor providing some excellent tracks, but in comparison to previos ASoT's, 2008 is not a patch on them.
People who own previous ASoT's may want to buy it anyway to find out for themselves - indeed, maybe it is just a transition that some people like. It is just opinion, after all...