"Im obsessed with this albumn well an truly my favourite more musical instruments and estranged melodies bundle together a psychadelic fantasy,truly underated.BEST TRACK=SUMMER'68"
"It's times like this you wonder why the hell syd barret left these songs are the most catchiest floyd songs ive ever listened to,barret is amazing,incredibly catchy a must buy,best track=lucifer sam"
"I guess this is incredible due to the amount of songs,but it spawned young children to listen to floyd,catchy,based on humans shutting their feelings inside a wall,best track=brick in the wall(2)"
"Gilmours best guitar work ever is seen here,a brilliant tribute to syd barret,wish you were here and shine on (part1-5)are truly too beutiful to miss richard wright proves incredible on this albumn."
"A brilliant concept albumn,incredibly overated compared to other floyd albumns but not without reason,this albums has waters written all over it,gilmours less inspired music ,rick wrights best here."
"George Orwell's animal farm based,another fantastic floyd concept albumn,dogs,sheep,pigs.Gilmour only now starts to prove he can play guitar beutifuly,B/T=dogs"
"Maybe too depressing to listen too,2nd albumn made during Syd barrets tragic mental breakdown,the bands loss and replacement of gilmour shows,still good,but syd barret is missing here."
"Very 80's a new direction for floyd,not for the worse though.Sounds like pop more than 70's rock but is truly amazing floyd make rock and pop now beutifully.B/T=One slip"
"seems short and incredibly unusual albumn by floyd,but does contain echoes which is 23 minutes long,waters childlike lyrics=santropez,seamus. waters only now lyrically producing.b/t=a pillow of winds"
"My least listened to floyd albums,i just cant explain it,its melodically mind numbing brilliance although at time long winded and not going anywhere,dont have a best track good album not for newcomers"
"If not for the live 2nd disc this would be no.13,my favourite album cover but not much else,no emotion or feeling with this,mind you the live disc is brilliant.b/t=sysyphus"
"Waters reminises the pain of war,politics and depression of the working class,only here can we realise the importance of rick wright who is missing,waters leaves ,his last albumn,then goes solo."