This is the first Christian romance book that I have read and the first Amish romance that I have read. I enjoyed the book, but not as much as I was anticipating. The book started off strong with the introduction of Sarah and Grant and then the sparks that fly as they flirt and try to resist the romantic ties, but then it kind of floundered in the middle. They know they are in love and want to marry the other person within about 1/4 - 1/3 of the way through the book and then it is just struggling to resist feelings until the very end of the book. This was a bit tiresome for me as I wanted to see the relationship grow and develop more. I understand that one of the people would have to make a huge lifestyle change and many sacrifices so it was a serious decision to make, but it is not the most fascinating reading to rehash the same problem over and over again. To fill the time, the author started inserting filler subplots like a disturbed teenage boy, a local animal show that mistreats its animals, a near fatal heart attack and so on. While all of these subplots are possible in even a tight-knit Amish community, I felt that they were introduced, resolved and dropped within a chapter or two and were just being used to fill the time. I wish that the author had spent more time on the courtship and Grant's learning about the Amish culture and trying to fit in and find a place with his neighbors.
I loved a lot of the details that the author included in this book, such as the type of goods Sarah sold in their family's stand, the types of plants she grows in her garden, local plants and animals, scenery, quilting, what is expected of an Amish girl, and many sweet scenes with Amish family gatherings. This was the most enjoyable part of the book for me and I felt like I was getting a good introduction to the Amish culture in a fast, enjoyable way. Nothing is overly worked in these details, which was refreshing, and the pages just fly by as you read. I also enjoyed all of the information about the animals that Grant tended while he was working. The descriptions were wonderful and the author has a lovely, clear writing style that is atmospheric and evocative without being overly flowery or bogged down. Kelly Long has a real knack for describing characters in just a few lines that made you fee like you had known them for years. I was easily able to identify with most of the characters in the book and really felt for Sarah, as most of the book is written from her point of view. I am a Christian and could empathize with Sarah trying to work out a balance between love and her faith and all that she knows. I am not sure what I would have done if I were in her shoes, but that would be a very difficult, if not impossible, decision to make!
In the end, I will recommend this book as it was an enjoyable read, but it has some limitations. I think that I will give this series another chance with the next book, though, as I really liked the author and felt like her characters were real people struggling with real problems. I really enjoyed her writing style and found this a quick, easy read. There is not a lot that happens in this book as far as exciting, action-packed scenes, but that is actually part of its charm. This book is a nice, old-fashioned romance with a kiss or two and lots of wonderful descriptions of the simple, beautiful life that the Amish choose to lead in our modern world. If you are looking for a clean romance for those of the Christian faith, this is a good one to pick up and enjoy.