I bought this after reading a very positive review in the T.E.S., and was rewarded with the real and very human way in which Swindells tells this story.
The best thing about 'Ruby Tanya' is that what happens is so believable - because the tensions in Tipton Lacy (setting of the book) are those faced in many areas of our country today. This book gets under the skin of the hype on either side of the asylum debate, and lets you meet the people at the heart of these issues.
Highlights the negative power of peer pressure (tabloids included in that!) and honours the courage of standing up for what you believe in. I particularly like that this includes young people having the 'right' view, independently of their parents - who may be in the wrong. You get a strong picture of how quickly tension can escalate and get out of hand. Shows very clearly that the mass hysteria response to issues like asylum seekers, risks not just being ill-informed, but an example to our children of how not to behave.
This book may be an invaluable school read. The chapters are short, and the story accessible. Chapters are narrated by each of the main characters, and you can 'feel' the difference in narrative voice. The exploration of family and friendship is convincing and compelling.
Only 4 out of 5 stars because of 2 reasons:
(1) Maybe it's just me, but many parts of the plot were more predictable than I'd have liked. (To be fair, I'm being harsh here - it is a children's book after all).
(2) Ruby's father. He undergoes some 'road to Damascus' type change, and I have no idea why, because it just suddenly happens. I found this really out of line with the development of his character, and was frustrated by the total lack of explanation or justification. Not a believable shift!
Don't let my two small concerns put you off this book - I read it avidly and was almost entirely drawn in by the whole experience. I will be recommending it to readers from year 7 - year 9 in particular, but this book needs to be read widely - as much for the issues it handles so well, as for the engaging experience of another success from Robert Swindells.